November 9,2026 · component study on R30

A stair that belongs in the house

Chris prefers type D: dark C-channel, substantial timber treads and handrail, with slim steel posts—closer to the supplied reference. The earlier chunky timber-post D did not capture his vision. This records a preference; Michelle’s final decision and the coordinated stair specification remain pending.

The stairwell, landings,18 rises, floor heights, walls, doors, ceiling, roof and furnishings are held fixed. These are unselected appearance concepts, with source and shop-detail qualifications—not a measured installation approval. Dark steel,2½ in red-oak treads and the same native lighting are common controls; final finishes remain undecided. Chris gives black and rust/patina equal weight in the coordinated all-steel study.

Your reference, translated to this house

Chris’s stair style reference: dark channel sides, timber treads and handrail, slim steel posts, horizontal infill
Owner-supplied inspiration. Its switchback, brickwork and room geometry are not copied.

What changes in D1 and D2

Keep the C-channel support and substantial 2½-inch oak treads. Replace chunky timber posts with slim dark steel posts and one continuous substantial oak top rail. The existing stairwell, straight flight, landing and house geometry remain fixed.

D1 · vertical steel: a more graphic steel infill, using the project’s quoted flat-bar dimensions. It is visually denser than the reference.

D2 · glass: preserves more of the reference’s openness with the same timber/steel frame. Glass cleaning and fixing details are trade-offs.

Horizontal infill · inspiration only: the Ontario residential guard provisions address climbability; the Appendix identifies ladder-like horizontal members as unsuitable for required guards. On that primary-source reading, the reference’s cable/rod arrangement is not offered as a prescriptive option. Any alternative solution needs documented designer, stairmaker and Township review.

Ontario Part 9 · Appendix A. Actual code pages are available in the source selector and evidence below.

1 · Choose a camera, then compare two options

Left comparison

Right comparison

Loading the checked comparison…

Start with D1 and D2: identical C-channel support, treads and timber/steel frame; only the infill changes. A, B, C and E remain available as earlier controls. The original five-option study, including the superseded chunky-post D, remains intact.

Keep your place

Saved locally on this browser; no project approval or final preference is recorded.

Starting from Meghan’s September 22 presentation: retain the warm timber and open stair character as a reference, then compare support and railing independently. Her lighting and finish proposals remain unselected; this study adds no light fixtures or furniture. The original presentation page is in the source selector.

2 · Options, trade-offs and actual cost basis

HSS means a hollow steel section. A stringer is the support below the steps; the guard prevents a fall at the open edge; the handrail is the graspable rail. Every modeled option uses the same 2½ in red-oak tread envelope, lowered from the unchanged tread tops. Open risers are an explicit study change from the generic closed-riser R30 mesh.

OptionStringer / guardWhy compare it / trade-offCAD cost basis
D1 · C-channel / timber / vertical steelDark twin channels; thick oak treads; slim steel posts; one oak cap; vertical flat-bar infillWarm, strong timber/steel character. More visual screening than the supplied reference.Unquoted revised hybrid. Prior component quotes are design references, not a new installed price.
D2 · C-channel / timber / glassSame channel, tread and frame; nominal 12 mm safety-glass envelopeMore open view. Cleaning, panel support and glass fixing remain to be resolved.Unquoted revised hybrid. The former timber/glass package is a historical benchmark only.
A · C-channel + meshTwin 12 in C-channels
Perforated mesh
Strong graphic edge; visibly robust
More visually busy; manufacturer toe/guard objection unresolved
$28,388.99 incl. HST
Steelhaus 2652 + Stairhaus 19808 actual attachment subtotals
B · Mono + vertical steelCentral 8×6 in HSS mono
Vertical flat-bar infill in common metal frame
Clearer side view; slim infill without glass cleaning
Common frame is a study control, not the all-flat-bar 2643 post/handrail specification
$26,987.79 incl. HST · illustrative component sum
Steelhaus 2643 + timber tread/nosing/install lines of 19809 only; illustrative allocation, unquoted combination
C · Mono + glassCentral 8×6 in HSS mono
12 mm glass in common metal frame
Most transparent view through the guard
Common frame differs from 19809 standoff/base-shoe details; cleaning and scope overlap
$43,778.46 incl. HST · attachment sum, overlap unresolved
2643 +19809 attachment sum; guard/install overlap unresolved
E · C-channel + vertical steel controlTwin 12 in C-channels
Vertical flat-bar infill in common metal frame
Control: compare with B for stringer alone
Unquoted combination; needs the same coordinated details
$26,275.89 incl. HST · illustrative component sum
Cross-quote component control, not supplier quotation

These are not interchangeable installed quotes. A’s attachments sum to $25,123.00 before HST; Alyssa’s email says $25,133.00—a $10.00 difference. C’s $38,742.00 before HST matches the attachment sum, but the steel guard/installation and glass guard/installation scopes may overlap. B/E are arithmetic component scenarios, not supplier quotations. Neither revised D has a quote; the older whole timber/glass package at $25,092.78 incl. HST is only a benchmark.

Controlled combinations, not exact shop proposals: A, B, C and E hold a 1½ in metal frame/cap envelope common, sourced from 2652. B/E use the 3/8×1½ in flat-bar infill from 2643; C uses 12 mm glass from 19809. B is not a literal depiction of 2643’s all-flat-bar posts/handrails, and C does not claim to show 19809’s standoffs/base shoe. Those mounts, full guard specifications and any resulting price changes require coordinated drawings and re-quotation.

Final paint/stain, engineering if required, backing/footings, temporary removal, field-measure revisions and any builder fee outside the supplier documents are excluded or unresolved. Glass quotes say 2–3 weeks after template for glass installation; no overall fabrication or delivery date is established. Steel treads remain a documented Michelle exploration; no dimensioned steel-tread product or matching installed price has been supplied, so no fabricated steel-tread specification is shown.

Real references: Stairhaus stair/railing gallery · Steelhaus, Ontario. Exact project estimate numbers and primary sheets are in the source selector below.

3 · The actual plans, designer reference and quotes

138 incurrent floor-to-floor height
18 rises7⅔ in each in R30
17 treadsplus the upper landing/nosing strip

A101 labels a 49¼ in stair-zone width; R30’s traced tread width is 46.48 in. These are not yet reconciled as the same datum. A nearby lower-level door is labelled 36 in on A101 while the opening inventory says 42 in. Upper-arrival/bookcase clearance, final nosings, guard posts, floor build-ups and field measurements require coordination. No wall, opening or stair width was altered to make an option fit.

Source drawing

Source → 2D → 3D →native →image evidence and retained failures

Actual source pages and complete, losslessly indexed local numeric geometry were supplied together to the real CLI review worker. Its result permits only a reversible study with qualifications; it does not grant an owner gate. All affected component changes are explicit; surrounding face records and tread-top coordinates are retained. Native imports bind actual loaded vertices and camera hashes. Photographs have separate pixel reviews; they do not inherit source certification.

4 · What needs a coordinated answer

Alyssa / stairmakers / designer: resolve the mesh-to-tread/toe interface, exact stringer section/weight, post and glass-shoe footprint, guard and graspable handrail heights, backing/load paths, door/landing clearances, complete headroom and a single non-overlapping installed scope. The supplier’s mesh warning remains open. Quote dimensions are study envelopes, not approved shop drawings.

Chris and Michelle: use the paired views to identify which support and railing character you want developed. Chris now prefers the revised D family; this is not a final system choice. Michelle’s final stair and finish choice remains pending. The 42-inch cap is a study control; graspability, final height/tolerance, attachments and glass engineering are not resolved. Keep the large-Oriel/upper-window coordination separate; R30 openings are retained here as context, not newly approved.

All comparison images and provenance

Every released native frame and photographic concept is available below. Failed attempts remain in the versioned study archive with defect/correction records.

D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Lower arrival · looking up · native model
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Lower arrival · looking up · native model
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Lower arrival · looking up · photographic concept
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Lower arrival · looking up · photographic concept
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Lower landing · side view · native model
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Lower landing · side view · native model
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Lower landing · side view · photographic concept
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Lower landing · side view · photographic concept
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Great Room · arrival context · native model
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Great Room · arrival context · native model
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Great Room · arrival context · photographic concept
D1 · Reference character + vertical steel · Great Room · arrival context · photographic concept
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Lower arrival · looking up · native model
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Lower arrival · looking up · native model
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Lower arrival · looking up · photographic concept
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Lower arrival · looking up · photographic concept
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Lower landing · side view · native model
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Lower landing · side view · native model
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Lower landing · side view · photographic concept
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Lower landing · side view · photographic concept
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Great Room · arrival context · native model
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Great Room · arrival context · native model
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Great Room · arrival context · photographic concept
D2 · Reference character + safety glass · Great Room · arrival context · photographic concept

Earlier images and original D