October 14 revised agreements — approval review, October 19

Later October 26 owner confirmation

Chris confirms the revised agreements have been signed in CoConstruct. This supersedes approval reminders and earlier Awaiting Approval observations. Keep Alyssa's October 21 confirmation with the agreements. Exact signature dates and executed copies were not re-read in this revision; no agent signed or approved anything. Earlier dated analysis is retained as history.

October 26 status — requested confirmations received

Alyssa's October 21 “Mendacity/Carothers Contract Revision” email expressly confirms that existing approved change orders, written scope decisions, payments/credits and fee/discount history carry forward without duplication, and that Mendacity Pictures Inc. is the contracting owner with Chris and Michelle signing on its behalf. ASK-121 is answered. Retain that email with the revised agreements. The October 20 request below is now fulfilled, not an outstanding prerequisite. No owner approval/signature is inferred; the October 26 live Mendacity proposal list still says Awaiting Approval. Earlier analysis remains historical.

October20 reconsideration: the earlier blanket hold recommendation was too strong and is superseded. The transfer reconciles and the principal negotiated protections remain. Seek narrow written confirmation preserving approved changes, payments/credits, fee and prompt-payment history, and confirming Mendacity corporate identity/signing capacity. The other date, notice and document-reference improvements below are housekeeping or scope-management follow-ups, not all prerequisites to approval. Approval is reasonable once the two material points are clear; no owner approval recorded. This is a document/commercial-risk review, not a legal enforceability opinion. The original October19 findings below are retained for context; their broad pre-approval framing is superseded by this update.

Evidence and method

Read both complete October 14 proposals in Chris's authenticated Chrome session, including estimates, clauses 1–25, exhibits and signature blocks. Compared the live approved July 21 cottage proposal and July 21 Mendacity proposal, and inspected the archived July 21 signed cottage PDF and July 14 Mendacity PDF. The signed cottage PDF clips the right-hand price column, including its total: text extraction and page rendering both confirm this limitation. The October 14 archive PDFs are notification emails, not the agreements themselves. Do not claim they supply the full terms.

The live July cottage is Approved, with Chris July 25 and Michelle/Steve August 13 signatures. July Mendacity remains Awaiting Approval; Michelle and Steve are dated August 13, Chris has no approval date. That is partial signing, not a fully executed agreement. Both October documents are Awaiting Approval. No approval/signature was entered.

Amounts and the septic transfer

Including HST unless specifiedCottageMendacity
Live July 21 base$1,634,179.47$204,705.35
October revision base$1,691,555.08$147,329.74
Change, calculated separately+$57,375.61−$57,375.61
Management fee, before HST$161,000.00$19,000.00

The transferred septic installation allowance is $50,774.88 before HST; with HST, $57,375.61. Mendacity retains $669.50 before HST for existing-tank pumping/decommissioning. The transfer arithmetic is correct. These are budget bases, not fixed-price promises or remaining balances, and the two contracts are not netted.

The previously reported signed-cottage total $1,639,197.40 and resulting $5,017.93 gap are not independently verified by the clipped archive PDF. The live July proposal instead agrees with the historical portal base. Preserve the old record as an archive conflict pending a complete original/export; do not characterize it as an established overcharge or insist PattyMac correct a proven pricing error. Today's live-to-live transfer comparison reconciles exactly.

October19 findings — materiality narrowed by October20 update

  1. Preserve the existing record explicitly. Both October documents are full replacement-form agreements with clause 23 saying previous agreements/understandings are superseded. List the approved change orders and written scope decisions that continue, preserve all prior payments and credits and the original prompt-payment history, and confirm no second management fee or duplicate 3% markup arises. The cottage still presents foundation/framing/timber/plumbing/HVAC as options alongside old base allowances. Mendacity likewise lists the approved well/blasting/excavation as options. These must not be read as new approvals, omissions or a second charge. A signed incorporation/precedence schedule is clearer than relying on portal display alone. This is a drafting risk, not a conclusion that existing rights are already lost.
  2. Replace stale schedule information. Mendacity clause 3 still says September 30, 2026 completion. Its document body says October 10 despite the October 14 title. Both attach July 15 schedules and July 16 drawings while Notable E still names the January 21 conceptual plan and clause 4 has no populated drawing list. Identify the governing drawings, later changes and current schedules. Chris confirms septic blasting is taking place October 19 with Bayroc expected to finish that day, and Aiden cannot start excavation until the following week. Confirm exact excavation dates and resulting foundation/steel/framing dates rather than inserting an assumed October 26 start or retaining the October 21 foundation promise.
  3. Make the Mendacity party and execution unambiguous. The owner is written as “Mendacity Pictures,” while the signature slots name Chris and Michelle personally without corporate capacity. Use the full correct corporate name and an authorized-signatory capacity. Clause 22 lists only Michelle's email; add Chris for formal notices. Contractor is PattyMac Services Inc.; retain/confirm its correct legal identity rather than changing it to match an informal invoice/payee label. Personal liability cannot be determined from this review; resolve the execution wording before signing.
  4. Clarify the foundation scope rewrite. The cottage folds the old concrete floor $22,557.00, ICF $82,799.94 and stone/weeper $10,197.00 into $115,553.94 before HST, an exact sum. It now includes the lower-level floor in the foundation description, but replaces the six-truckload/8-inch interior stone/6-inch weeper description with “Site construction conditions will dictate actual aggregate required.” That is a real scope wording change beyond the septic transfer. Confirm the approved MBG scope/engineered requirements govern and how any actual aggregate adjustment is quoted and authorized. Do not misstate the consolidation as an extra $32,754.00 or double-count the slab.

A short amendment to the existing cottage agreement plus a corrected Mendacity agreement would be a practical way to record the intended change, if PattyMac agrees. Do not rewrite supplier options into new approvals, reopen accepted winter T&M or the accepted demolition explanation, or imply that today's meeting approved unpriced landscape work.

Protections retained, not new negotiation demands

The live cottage clause-by-clause text comparison after BUILDING AGREEMENT differs only in agreement date and removal of historical signature dates for the new approval form. It retains invoice backup/time records, ten-business-day payment wording, 5% management-fee discount conditioned on each invoice within 14 calendar days, two quotes above $25,000 unless waived, notice above 10% allowance overrun, written schedule updates, holdback clause 5.9, narrow CDE wording, insurance requirement, mutual indemnity and prior-approval photo restriction. Rates and management fees were not increased in the compared forms. The estimate scope changes above are separate from this unchanged terms comparison.

Holdback wording is present; invoice26-1847's accounting treatment remains unresolved despite owner payment October 19. Ontario's Construction Act has statutory holdback provisions independent of whether the agreement repeats them. This review does not determine the applicable lien/holdback release dates or certify compliance. Official source checked October 19: Ontario Construction Act, particularly sections 6.2 and 22.

Well — what is known and what still needs an answer

Gibbins estimate2572 dated August24 has a printed subtotal $23,195.72, HST $3,015.46 and supplier total $26,211.18. The approved Mendacity CO is $26,997.50 including the 3% fee and HST, approved by Chris September1. It covers drilling (220-foot minimum charge), casing, pump/control, pressure tank and installation; trenching excavator is excluded. This is not an assurance of final depth, water quality, yield or completion.

The well is already deposit-funded: invoice26-1713 includes the $11,597.87 before-HST 50% Gibbins well deposit (supplier7179); Chris paid that PattyMac invoice September8. A deposit is not evidence drilling has occurred.

The October19 well CO still displays Approved–Not billed; that label alone is not reliable evidence of invoice or field-work status. The full published Mendacity Gantt contains nine tasks and no named well task. Code73 shows $18,197.87 actuals, but invoices include other CDE items; do not allocate that whole code to well completion. No drilling log, completed test/commissioning record or named drilling date was found in the reviewed October correspondence/texts. Ask Alyssa whether drilling has occurred, otherwise its booked date, and the pump/trenching/connection/testing sequence and records if completed.

Meeting outcome and communication

Owner reports the October19 meeting went as expected: road layout confirmed; Michelle from PattyMac was asked for a property path/landscape layout and estimate; return visit needed after blast rock is removed to assess possibilities and required works. No separate rock-removal approval or tree safety finding was stated. Preserve those open questions without representing the meeting as no progress. Alyssa email shortened to a focused post-meeting follow-up; older pricing/coordination questions remain in the ask register, not silently closed.