{
  "as_of": "2026-11-12",
  "status": "owner-authorized studies built; all aesthetic selections pending",
  "revision_order_authorized": true,
  "model_approval": null,
  "layout": {
    "candidate_count": 42,
    "family_count": 7,
    "recommendation_for_review": "lake-facing-sofa-dx-12-d400",
    "control": {
      "id": "control-dx+0-d400",
      "family": "control",
      "note": "Current P3-2 retained as control",
      "seats": [
        [
          "sofa",
          [
            532,
            398,
            84,
            36,
            180
          ],
          3
        ],
        [
          "loveseat",
          [
            480,
            483,
            66.5,
            36,
            270
          ],
          2
        ],
        [
          "green chair",
          [
            548.0,
            474,
            32.7,
            28,
            230
          ],
          1
        ]
      ],
      "extra": [
        [
          "coffee table",
          [
            486,
            398,
            40,
            24,
            0
          ]
        ]
      ],
      "dining_centre_y": 400,
      "routes_bottleneck_in": {
        "entry-to-nook": 32.0,
        "entry-to-Muskoka door": 58.0,
        "kitchen/island-to-lake glass": 46.0,
        "nook-to-dining/Muskoka": 32.0,
        "entry-to-lake glass (living)": 32.0,
        "bar-to-seating": 32.0,
        "entry-to-casement-access": 32.0
      },
      "route_failures": [],
      "actual_footprint_collisions": [],
      "extended_table_route_failures": [
        "kitchen/island-to-lake glass: 26.0in < 32in"
      ],
      "lower_glazing_frontage_obscured_in": 109.5,
      "casement_access_route_in": 32.0,
      "score_lower_better": 49.3,
      "places_including_bench": 9
    },
    "proposed": {
      "id": "lake-facing-sofa-dx-12-d400",
      "family": "lake-facing-sofa",
      "note": "Sofa faces the lake; loveseat on dining-side return; lounge near NW",
      "seats": [
        [
          "sofa",
          [
            482,
            356,
            84,
            36,
            90
          ],
          3
        ],
        [
          "loveseat",
          [
            548,
            412,
            66.5,
            36,
            180
          ],
          2
        ],
        [
          "green chair",
          [
            438.0,
            478,
            32.7,
            28,
            315
          ],
          1
        ]
      ],
      "extra": [
        [
          "coffee table",
          [
            486,
            410,
            40,
            24,
            0
          ]
        ]
      ],
      "dining_centre_y": 400,
      "routes_bottleneck_in": {
        "entry-to-nook": 34.0,
        "entry-to-Muskoka door": 43.1,
        "kitchen/island-to-lake glass": 46.0,
        "nook-to-dining/Muskoka": 34.0,
        "entry-to-lake glass (living)": 34.0,
        "bar-to-seating": 43.1,
        "entry-to-casement-access": 34.0
      },
      "route_failures": [],
      "actual_footprint_collisions": [],
      "extended_table_route_failures": [
        "entry-to-nook: 24.0in < 32in",
        "kitchen/island-to-lake glass: 24.0in < 32in",
        "nook-to-dining/Muskoka: 24.0in < 32in",
        "entry-to-lake glass (living): 24.0in < 28in",
        "bar-to-seating: 24.0in < 30in",
        "entry-to-casement-access: 24.0in < 28in"
      ],
      "lower_glazing_frontage_obscured_in": 42.9,
      "casement_access_route_in": 34.0,
      "score_lower_better": 19.31,
      "places_including_bench": 9
    },
    "why": "Clears former loveseat/window corner and reveals green chair; retains all seats. Sofa back faces entrance, and main sofa no longer directly faces fire. This is a tradeoff for owner review, not an established global best.",
    "limits": [
      "Furniture-envelope numerical screening; current chair envelope, assumed occupied-knee zones and Great Room study boundary",
      "Normal table position only: extension creates24in route failures and needs a separate event arrangement",
      "Human-use circulation, actual chair pull-out and full door swing need physical/product set-out",
      "Lower-glazing frontage penalty is not a percentage of lake-view occlusion",
      "Exterior scene not surveyed; photographs illustrative beyond unmodelled space"
    ]
  },
  "island": {
    "fridge_x": [
      580.76,
      604.76
    ],
    "fridge_depth_retained_in": 23.1,
    "knee_bays_x": [
      [
        541.5,
        575.5
      ],
      [
        610,
        644
      ]
    ],
    "knee_clear_depth_in": 12.75,
    "cooking_drawer_box_depth_in": 24,
    "cooking_drawer_y": [
      217.15,
      241.15
    ],
    "knee_back_y": 264.21,
    "drawer_to_knee_partition_gap_in": 23.06,
    "residual_volume_policy": "retained for access/coordination until a usable supported storage detail is established; not claimed as storage capacity",
    "open_items": [
      "actual refrigeration choice and full cabinet depth",
      "cooktop underside/service envelope and heat separation",
      "drawer hardware/loading/open door travel",
      "separate appliance electrical requirements"
    ]
  },
  "bar": {
    "parent_sha256": "d87523947fcc9acc52847f41c739e2ac4bf7822817bba78f2c3bddeda7266712",
    "study_record": {
      "parent_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-12-arrival-island-seating-r1/models-r2/preferred-v7-spatial.json",
      "parent_sha256": "d87523947fcc9acc52847f41c739e2ac4bf7822817bba78f2c3bddeda7266712",
      "mode": "flair",
      "metal_finish_option": "bronze",
      "fronts_and_counter_footprint_retained": true,
      "left_clear_coffee_bay_y": [
        280.5,
        311
      ],
      "counter_height_in": 36,
      "valance_underside_in": 64,
      "clear_height_in": 28,
      "raised_lever_reservation_in": 26,
      "lever_clearance_status": "2in nominal reservation margin only; exact manufacturer raised operating sweep still unverified",
      "Flair_proxy_base_in": [
        14,
        8.5
      ],
      "manufacturer_envelope_conflict": "current page says just over14x8in; FAQ says13x7.5in/11H lowered; use larger provisional base and explicit operating reservation",
      "milk_equipment": "not displayed permanently: it crowds the short prep zone; concealed/removable accessory may be tested after exact product selection",
      "silver_proxy_assumptions": {
        "trays": [
          [
            22,
            16
          ],
          [
            20,
            16
          ],
          [
            18,
            16
          ]
        ],
        "bucket_each_with_handle_envelope": [
          11.7,
          10.5,
          10.5
        ],
        "cups_total": 15,
        "cup_diameter_height": [
          3.2,
          4.0
        ]
      },
      "miniatures": "six displayed, optional removable20-bottle collection storage to develop; no fixed20-item display requirement",
      "storage_open_items": [
        "actual silver sizes/shape before fabrication",
        "sink bowl and trap versus right bucket bay",
        "tray rack/shelf joinery",
        "device cable routing, outlets and ventilation"
      ],
      "owner_selection": null
    },
    "qualification": "all working/storage arrangements are unselected inferred proxies; internal objects modelled behind retained closed fronts; no claim of construction/product fit"
  },
  "metals": {
    "proposal": "Black remains dominant in structure, windows, pulls and kitchen tap; restrained bronze repeated on the bar tap/rails/pulls can act as localized jewellery. Silver collection is a movable accent, not a requirement to make fixed fittings silver.",
    "reason": "Bronze warms walnut and olive stone; all-black is calmer but loses that glow. Do not match structural beams mechanically to every fitting. Compare finish families in same light; avoid nearly-matching bronzes from unrelated lines.",
    "status": "designer recommendation and unselected alternatives; owner questions were not finish directions",
    "source": "https://www.kohler.ca/en/inspiration/articles/kitchen/design-trend-mixed-metals-in-the-kitchen"
  },
  "coffee": {
    "priority": [
      "beautiful at rest",
      "espresso or pour-over use",
      "alcohol service"
    ],
    "Flair_is_owned": false,
    "manufacturer_prices": {
      "date": "2026-11-12",
      "currency": "USD",
      "58_Plus_2": 699.0,
      "49_PRO": 359.0,
      "qualification": "Manufacturer US list, not Canadian delivered quotation; excludes grinder, kettle, tax/freight/FX. No purchase instruction."
    },
    "footprint_qualification": "58Plus2 page advertises base just over14x8in, conflicting smaller FAQ;13.5x7.5x11in assembled49PRO elsewhere on same page conflicts17x13x5 spec. Neither raised lever sweep is certified. Current14x8.5in proxy and28in shelf-free height are a study reservation only.",
    "operating_sequence": "Fill kettle at sink; grind/weigh beside brewer; pull espresso at clear shelf-free end; rinse/removable knock box stored below. Kettle/grinder can be put away for alcohol service; retain broad stone view.",
    "milk": "No permanent milk steamer in current composition: it crowds the working strip. Consider a removable compact unit only after a real envelope and attractive placement pass.",
    "alternative": "49PRO lower price/smaller published assembled footprint but different49mm system and manual heat management; pour-over offers the calmest display but does not make espresso.",
    "sources": [
      "https://flairespresso.com/products/flair-58-plus-2",
      "https://flairespresso.com/products/flair-49-pro"
    ]
  },
  "storage": {
    "silver": "15cups studied:3 on shelves,12 concealed;3 trays vertical in left rack;2 buckets in base bays. Assumptions: cups3.2dia x4H, trays22/20/18H x16D, buckets11.7W including handles x10.5D x10.5H. These are labelled proxies, not owner measurements or universal standard sizes.",
    "miniatures": "Six displayed, rotated from changing~20 collection. Removable12x10x5in nominal tray for remainder can live above centre bucket; this is an inferred accessory detail, not a required20-bottle shrine. Varying bottle shapes may change capacity.",
    "tequila_wine": "Two short tequila bottles on upper shelf; taller selected bottles need lower concealed height check. Red wine in island fridge; confirm actual model temperature range for red-wine use, venting and rack capacity. Do not treat ordinary fridge or cooler as interchangeable.",
    "residual_island": "Two cooking-side24in drawer-box banks use accessible depth behind stool knees; central residual volume is held for service, not inaccessible deep cupboards. Current knee depth12.75in remains a comfort limitation to improve at final millwork set-out, rather than claim all voids usable.",
    "open": [
      "sink/trap against right bucket bay",
      "shelf loading and thermal/moisture protection",
      "real appliance operating sweep and plug/cable routing",
      "coffee cleanup/grounds storage",
      "actual refrigerator and cooktop underside/heat/electrical coordination"
    ]
  },
  "Nada_questions_DRAFT_ONLY": [
    "Confirm engineering viability of preferred Oriel before considering fallback C.",
    "For the nook gas stove only, confirm chosen product/listed hearth and combustible clearances/flue with reduced floor pad in front of masonry.",
    "Does Nada permit any actual Rumford masonry/hearth narrowing after technical review? Until explicit response preserve its entire configuration."
  ],
  "separate_nook_prompt": "docs/HANDOFF_GPT/NOOK_OPTION_C_AGENT_START_PROMPT_2026-11-12.md",
  "Oriel_preferred": true,
  "option_C": "fallback only; independent continuation, no changes in this study"
}
