{
  "reviews": [
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-great-room-wide-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-great-room-wide-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Fireplace remains left, kitchen right, and entrance centrally behind the seating."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, central entrance and divided kitchen window retain their native arrangement and approximate proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "High timber ceiling and lower flat kitchen ceiling retain their profiles."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer bearing",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Timbers meeting the diagonal steel read as terminating against its side. Continuous over-beam members resting on a thin nailer are not convincingly preserved or demonstrated."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both prominent black steel members retain their positions and overall profiles."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall masonry chimney, raised rectangular aperture, front seat, leather cushions and side firewood storage remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair construction is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required bookcase construction cannot be assessed from this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Cabinet banks and island broadly correspond, but pendants obscure the hood canopy and prevent confirmation of its complete pyramid geometry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The foreground mustard pillow becomes a draped textile, and additional thin magazines appear beside the coffee-table books. These are object changes rather than surface finishing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three pendants, two visible recessed lights and two fireplace sconces retain their approximate positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing and aspect",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use 3:2 framing with closely corresponding architectural landmarks and foreground cropping."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Textile substitution and added coffee-table styling violate the unchanged-object requirement."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Dark stain is present, but required continuous bearing geometry is not established."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible steel has a consistent restrained black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney reads as grey linear coursed stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal hearth bench with cognac cushions and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark projecting seat, cognac leather and cylindrical bolsters are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV appearance",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Landscape art, pale matte and thin dark bezel sit close to the wood wall; brand cannot be verified visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone-type chairs with natural paper cord",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Black curved chair frames are visible, but seats are too obscured to confirm paper cord."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible tabletop has a convincing walnut appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Wall treatment reads noticeably peach/beige under the strongly amber lighting."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both treatments are visible. Wood replacing the kitchen floor placeholder is acceptable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut and olive surfaces read appropriately; the complete hood shape is obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly glowing globes hang on dark rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the assessable view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stairs are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Textured upholstery, pillows, books and stoneware look attractive and restrained; olive tree and floor lamp are not visible."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Required continuous joist-over-steel bearing detail is not demonstrated.",
        "Foreground mustard pillow is replaced by a draped textile.",
        "Additional magazines appear on the coffee table.",
        "Walls read peach/beige rather than warm white."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, but fails unchanged-object fidelity and required joist continuity. Return to spatial correction and renewed review; reduce the peach wall cast during finishing."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-fireplace-hearth-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-fireplace-hearth-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "material_only",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, bench wall, entry and kitchen retain their relative orientations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, entry glazing and kitchen window retain their openings and principal divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood ceiling and lower kitchen ceiling follow the native profiles."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer bearing",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No obvious broken or offset member appears, but the steel obscures enough of the bearing junctions that continuous passage and thin nailer support cannot be confirmed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The large black beam and visible structural intersections retain their positions and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Opening, stone mass, projecting front seat, leather cushion, bolsters and adjacent log storage follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible shelving and rear storage retain their placement and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island edge and cropped hood retain their native arrangement; concealed details cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofas, cushions, throw, lounge chair, dining furniture, table objects, lamp and artwork retain their arrangement and approximate scale. No plant is visible in either frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two chimney sconces, one visible pendant and the visible recessed light retain their locations; no additional fixture is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 and preserve the same foreground cropping, perspective and left/right relationships without an obvious camera change."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear object, fixture or hardware addition or removal is visible."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut roof joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The visible timbers read dark walnut, but continuity and bearing are partly obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed steel reads consistently matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney stone reads grey, coursed and predominantly linear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite hearth bench with cognac leather cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Leather and bolsters are convincing, but the seat reads as a thin black ledge over a substantial rough-stone plinth rather than a clearly expressed floating charcoal-granite bench."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV presentation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The wood-wall display has a thin black frame, pale matte and landscape art. Brand and exact flush mounting cannot be verified visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone-type chairs with natural cord",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dining chairs have black curved frames and natural woven seats."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible tabletop reads warm walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read softly textured warm ivory rather than distinctly peach."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm timber flooring and dark entry tile are visible; intended timber replaces the native kitchen floor placeholder appropriately."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinetry, counters and cropped hood convey the requested materials; the full hood shape is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible pendant has an opal globe and black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The visible left bookcase reads as an all-walnut carcass and shelving, without the requested black steel frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The nook stove is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Textured cushions, fringed throw, stoneware and the foreground lamp feel coordinated and uncluttered. An olive tree is not visible."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Hearth bench lacks the requested clear floating charcoal-granite expression.",
        "Visible bookcase lacks the requested black steel framing.",
        "Joist continuity and thin-nailer bearing cannot be conclusively verified from this view."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with no clear geometry or camera departure. Material preferences remain unresolved at the hearth bench and bookcase; joist bearing needs a clearer view. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-timber-steel-bearing-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-timber-steel-bearing-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible wall returns, large glazing divisions and right-side high window retain their native positions, proportions and orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling planes and their intersections with beams and chimney match the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer bearing",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Joist segments align across the foreground steel without visible offsets or invented end joints. The narrow bearing strip remains; portions behind the steel are occluded."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The dominant diagonal steel member retains its section, exposed end, position and intersections."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace/chimney/hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney mass and ceiling junction match. Firebox, hearth and benches are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair, bookcases and kitchen cabinets/island/hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside this upward-looking camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No furnishings or styling objects are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three recessed lights and the cropped black suspension rods/canopy retain their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with matching normalized beam, chimney, glazing and light landmarks; no visible mirroring or reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, lights and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No visible additions or omissions. The outdoor landscape supplies photographic background through existing glazing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stained timber contrasts with the warm ceiling; visible alignment is continuous across steel occlusion."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed steel reads as consistent matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney reads as grey ashlar with horizontal courses and elongated stones; exact product identity cannot be established from pixels."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite hearth bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bench is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV and its supporting wall are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wishbone-type black dining chairs and walnut table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible wall strips read warm off-white rather than peach, with subtle surface texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Floor is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Black rods and canopy are visible and consistent; pendant shades are cropped out."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel and seat are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "This architectural ceiling detail excludes the styling objects."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible camera scope. The photograph preserves native geometry and framing and presents an attractive, convincingly photographic timber/steel detail. Hidden bearing construction and whole-room styling are not verified by this view."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-entry-arrival-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-entry-arrival-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main glazing wall, right chimney wall and left adjoining opening retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible glazing banks, mullions, horizontal divisions and left openings remain substantially consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Timber ceiling retains the native slope and supporting wall relationships."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists over steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timber runs remain aligned across the steel crossing; no clear broken or offset member is apparent. Thin nailer detail is difficult to resolve."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible black steel members retain their positions and crossing arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney edge and side bench retain their arrangement, cushion and two end bolsters; the fireplace front is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No inspectable stair flight or infill."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped foreground counter and cabinet end are visible; the complete island and hood cannot be checked."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plant",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph adds a mustard knitted throw over the far sofa while also showing a mustard cushion near the foreground sofa. The native shows a single mustard rectangular cushion-like object between the sofas, without that draped throw."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible pendant globes including the cropped left globe, floor lamp, two wall sconces and visible recessed lights correspond."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 composition with matching handedness and substantially corresponding architectural framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The added sofa throw violates the requested object-preservation requirement."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stained timber and continuous aligned runs are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed steel reads as restrained matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right chimney uses grey stone in horizontal courses."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible side bench has a dark projecting slab, cognac upholstery and two bolsters."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV above side bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The relevant wall area is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone-type chairs with natural cord",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dining chairs have black curved frames and pale woven seats."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Table reads as warm walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under golden sunlight, without a strong peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light timber floor and cropped charcoal entry paving are visible; intended wood replacing the kitchen placeholder is acceptable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Cropped walnut cabinetry and muted counter are visible, but the hood and full kitchen treatment cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible pendants match this treatment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the camera view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the camera view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel assembly is outside the camera view."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair details are outside the camera view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Textured upholstery, stoneware, olive tree and floor lamp form an attractive, uncluttered composition."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added mustard sofa throw changes the native object inventory and mustard textile arrangement."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with broadly preserved architecture and camera. Fails strict object fidelity because of the added throw; reconcile the styling with the native scene and review again. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-kitchen-island-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-kitchen-island-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen walls, adjoining passage and foreground right return retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible kitchen window and upper clerestories retain their overall outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling and adjoining higher ceiling arrangement remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Roof joist continuity and nailer bearing",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The cropped upper-left timber does not expose enough of its crossing and bearing to verify continuity or the thin nailer."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The large diagonal beam retains its extent, alignment and visible junctions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace and front hearth seat are outside the frame; only part of the side bench is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible railing remains in the same passage location with vertical infill."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required bookcase assemblies are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinet banks, island footprint, induction rings and pyramid hood retain their arrangement and apparent scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cropped chair, sofa, side bench, artwork and firewood remain in their corresponding locations; no new plant or staging objects appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both island pendants retain their positions and black suspension rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use 3:2 framing with closely corresponding wall, island, hood and beam landmarks; no reversal is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph introduces a conspicuous horizontal side fitting on the sink faucet that is absent from the native frame."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Timber colour is visible, but complete joist continuity and bearing are cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible architectural steel reads as dark black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace stone is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite hearth bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The specified front hearth bench is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The cropped framed artwork cannot establish the specified TV, bezel or mounting."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone chairs with natural paper cord",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a chair back is visible; its seat material cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining table is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls, not peach",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Walls and kitchen ceiling read strongly peach/tan under the amber treatment rather than warm white."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood and the dark entry zone are present. Replacing the native pale kitchen-floor placeholder with wood is intended."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three finishes are clearly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two softly glowing opal globes hang from black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible railing portion has slim vertical black bars; full stair construction is obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Composition is uncluttered, with convincing wood, metal, glass and daylight. Specific pillows, throw, stoneware, olive tree and floor lamp are not visible."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added faucet side hardware differs from the binding native frame.",
        "Excessive amber/peach treatment compromises the warm-white wall preference."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, but fails the strict object-preservation requirement because of added faucet hardware. Return to spatial/object correction and renewed review; also neutralize the peach wall cast."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-nook-stove-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-nook-stove-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, bookcase wall and adjoining living area retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible background openings retain their apparent outlines; no clear opening addition or deletion."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundaries show no clear slope change."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer bearing",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joist-to-steel bearing connections are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No sufficiently exposed structural beam permits comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Nook stove, vertical flue, floor plate and stone chimney retain their placement and overall proportions. The main fireplace and bench are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stair opening, timber handrail, dark posts and vertical infill retain their layout."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two tall bays, shelf levels and lower closed storage remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph adds a mustard sofa cushion and a long fringed throw; the native shows a narrow mustard element along the sofa top, without that cushion or hanging textile."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible suspended pendant retains its location; no additional fixture is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2, with closely corresponding chimney, stove, bookcase and railing landmarks and unchanged handedness."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The added sofa styling prevents an object-preserving finish pass."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only small ceiling/timber fragments are visible; continuity cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dark metal elements read as restrained matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The chimney reads as large, chunky rectangular rubble blocks rather than thin linear Ashlar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a small upholstered fragment appears beyond the chimney; the assembly cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV above side bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The relevant wall is obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone-type chairs with natural cord",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "A distant chair silhouette is insufficient to verify seat material and construction."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible table has a warm dark walnut appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm ivory with subtle surface variation, without a strong peach cast."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible flooring reads as warm light wood; a dark entry-floor patch remains visible at left."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen finishes and equipment are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible pendant has an opal globe and slender black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark frames and warm walnut shelves/storage are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The compact black stove and black flue remain prominent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Slim vertical dark infill accompanies timber rails and treads."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The composition is attractive and uncluttered, although the added sofa styling violates native object fidelity."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added mustard sofa cushion and hanging fringed throw.",
        "Chimney stone remains too chunky for the requested linear Ashlar appearance."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with closely preserved framing. Fail for added sofa objects; correct object fidelity before renewed finishing. Linear stone appearance also needs revision. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-nook-window-seat-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-nook-window-seat-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone chimney left, Oriel wall ahead and bookcase right retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main Oriel opening, narrow glazed return and adjacent tall glazing retain broadly matching proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundary retains the native orientation; this crop provides limited slope evidence."
        },
        {
          "check": "Roof joists and continuous bearing",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Photograph introduces projecting timber ceiling members where the native frame shows a plain ceiling. Continuous passage over steel and thin-nailer bearing cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Structural beam and joist-bearing junction are outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible nook stove, flue and stone chimney retain their placement and broad scale; main hearth bench is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground timber rail and vertical dark infill retain the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right-hand bookcase and visible shelf divisions remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Seat remains inside the window recess; no pillows, plants or loose interior decor are added. Upholstery seams refine the native seat surface."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No visible light fixtures are added or removed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use the same 3:2 aspect and closely corresponding window, stove, shelving and railing landmarks without reversal."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Added projecting ceiling timbers change the binding native geometry."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible timbers read warm medium brown; continuity and bearing over steel are unproven."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dark metalwork reads matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Chimney reads as large, chunky rectangular blocks rather than thin linear Ashlar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal hearth bench, cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Main fireplace seating is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV wall is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wishbone-type dining chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining chairs are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining table is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Wall reads distinctly beige or peach under the warm treatment rather than warm white."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor is warm light wood; entry stone is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Pendant locations are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right-hand shelving combines dark metal edging with dark walnut-like shelves."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black stove and vertical flue remain clearly visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with continuous plaster below",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Recessed cushion, thin dark underside and continuous plaster below retain the floating appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible railing has timber handrail and slim vertical dark bars; channel and treads are outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Composition is uncluttered, with convincing upholstery and attractive daylight; specified styling accessories are outside this view."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added projecting ceiling timbers absent from the native frame.",
        "Chimney stone is chunky rather than linear Ashlar.",
        "Wall colour reads beige/peach rather than warm white."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, but fails native fidelity because ceiling members were added. Return to spatial correction; retain the stone and wall-colour findings for finishing."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-entry-arrival-01",
      "review_round": "model-facts",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-entry-arrival-01-model-facts/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Glazing wall, left adjoining opening and right chimney retain their orientation and solid returns."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both tall glazing banks retain their visible mullions, transoms and relative proportions; the left opening and narrow window remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood ceiling planes and their sloping junctions match the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible joists remain continuous above the black steel support, without apparent breaks or offsets. The support interface reads as a thin strip rather than a displaced timber."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The prominent crossing steel members retain their locations, depths and connections."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney edge, partial firebox and side bench retain their placement and proportions; cushion and bolsters remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The staircase is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No bookcase is sufficiently visible to compare."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible foreground island retains its footprint and countertop profile. Other cabinetry and the hood are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plant",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sofas, dining set, lounge chair, coffee table, bench and single plant retain their arrangement and scale. Coffee-table books and bowl remain. The ochre throw occupies its specified sofa-back location."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible pendant globes, including the cropped left globe, floor lamp, chimney sconces and visible recessed lights correspond to the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with matching principal intersections, furniture occlusions and left/right orientation; no material reframing is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, decor, lights or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete addition or omission is apparent. Realistic foliage, upholstery and the draped throw elaborate existing modeled objects."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Continuous dark walnut roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stained timbers contrast with warm ceiling boards and continue above the steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed structural steel reads consistently matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney has grey, horizontally coursed ashlar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Side bench reads as a dark projecting slab with cognac leather upholstery and retained bolsters."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The intended TV wall is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone-type chairs with natural cord",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dining chairs have black curved frames and pale woven seats."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Table reads as warm walnut with the retained rectangular proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white textured plaster; golden sunlight does not make them appear peach-painted."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light wood flooring and foreground charcoal stone are visible. Wood replacing the kitchen floor placeholder is appropriate."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible island has dark walnut fronts and a muted olive-grey honed counter. Hood and remaining kitchen are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globes are softly luminous opal glass suspended on black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases cannot be assessed from this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel seat is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stairs are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Textured pillows, ochre throw, stoneware, books, olive tree and floor lamp form a cohesive arrangement without clutter."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and attractiveness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing textile, leather, wood and glass detail, coherent sunlight and natural exterior depth create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible camera scope: convincingly photographic, with no concrete geometry, object or camera departure identified. Hidden features and owner approval are not established."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-fireplace-hearth-01",
      "review_round": "model-facts",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-fireplace-hearth-01-model-facts/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall arrangement, clerestory divisions, entry glazing and kitchen window remain consistent with the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling planes and visible joist paths agree. No visible joist break or offset occurs at the steel; the thin bearing interface remains visually consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The large horizontal steel beam and visible end connections retain their positions and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney perimeter, raised aperture, projecting front seat, cushion and bolsters retain the native arrangement. Side bench and log storage remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left shelving retains its shelf divisions, footprint and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island edges, induction surface and cropped hood retain their locations and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sofas, chair, dining furniture, cushions and coffee table remain aligned. The ochre throw correctly develops the native mustard block; two books and one bowl remain on the table. No added plant or conspicuous extra decor appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sconces, recessed light and pendant retain their count and placement. Rounded photographic fixture surfaces plausibly refine the native faceting."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images retain the 3:2 composition, matching foreground crops, landmark relationships and handedness, without a material viewpoint change."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete object, light, decor or hardware addition or omission is evident within the visible scope."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut roof joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers read as dark walnut and retain continuous paths."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed steel has a consistent restrained black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney stone reads as grey linear ashlar with natural variation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite hearth bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark projecting slab, cognac leather seat and two bolsters are clearly expressed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV appearance",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The wall display has a thin black bezel, matted landscape art and a flush appearance above the side bench; brand cannot be established from pixels."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wishbone-type dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chairs have black curved frames and natural cord seats."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The cropped tabletop reads as warm walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as softly textured warm white under warm lighting, without a pronounced peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light timber flooring and dark entry tiles are present. Replacing the kitchen floor placeholder with timber is correct."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinetry, muted olive counters and cropped stainless hood follow the requested palette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible pendant has an opal globe and black suspension rod."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible shelving reads as dark framing with walnut shelves and backing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The nook stove is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel seat is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Textured pillows, ochre throw, stoneware and the cropped floor lamp create a coherent, uncluttered interior. An olive tree is not visible."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible camera scope. The photograph convincingly preserves the native composition and objects while providing attractive, professionally styled materials and lighting. This visual review does not establish installation dimensions or owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-great-room-wide-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-great-room-wide-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall arrangement, clerestory openings, rear doorway and divided kitchen window correspond to the native frame; no clear opening addition or omission."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The sloping timber ceiling and lower flat kitchen ceiling retain their native relationship."
        },
        {
          "check": "Roof joist continuity and bearing",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible joist runs align across the steel without an apparent break or offset. Concealed bearing and thin-nailer construction cannot be independently confirmed from these pixels."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both prominent black steel members retain their positions, depth and intersections."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth benches",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The chimney, raised opening, front seat and adjoining cushioned bench retain the native composition. Foreground furniture obscures portions of the hearth."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside the useful visible coverage."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinet banks, island, induction surface and visible hood portions correspond; pendants obscure much of the hood."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofas, dining furniture, cushions, artwork, bowls and coffee-table books correspond in placement and approximate scale. The ochre throw correctly develops the native mustard block into draped fabric."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lights and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three pendant globes, two chimney sconces and visible recessed fixtures correspond. No definite additional fixture or hardware is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera and object inventory",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The 3:2 aspect, handedness, framing and principal occlusions closely match. No material camera shift or definite added or removed object is evident."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark walnut appearance and aligned continuous runs are convincing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed steel reads as consistent restrained black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey, horizontally coursed stone matches the requested appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal hearth bench, cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible charcoal bench edges, cognac leather cushion and cylindrical bolsters support the preference; full floating clearance is obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV appearance",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The thin black frame, broad matte and landscape art read as a flush art-mode display; brand cannot be verified visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wishbone-type chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black curved frames and characteristic back supports fit the requested type; cord seats are largely obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The table has a convincing warm walnut finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm ivory with subtle texture, without a pronounced peach cast."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both finishes are visible. Wood replacing the native kitchen placeholder is an intended correction."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut and subdued olive surfaces are convincing; visible stainless hood portions agree, although the canopy is substantially obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly luminous opal globes retain black suspension rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No useful bookcase coverage."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seat is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Textured upholstery, wool throw, cushions, books and stoneware feel coherent and uncluttered. Olive tree and floor lamp are not visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and attractiveness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Natural light, material texture, upholstery and exterior views create a convincing, attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible camera scope: convincing photographic finishing with no definite geometry, object or camera departure. Hidden construction details and out-of-frame preferences remain unverified; this is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-kitchen-island-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-kitchen-island-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, kitchen window divisions, clerestories and left circulation openings retain the native arrangement and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling and adjoining raised ceiling remain consistent. Visible timber crosses the black steel without an apparent break or offset; concealed bearing details cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible black beam positions, depth and continuity remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace assembly is outside the frame; only part of the side bench and wood storage is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a partial railing is visible; stair construction and bookcases cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, induction and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinet banks, island envelope, induction location and pyramid hood retain their native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Sink hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph depicts a conspicuous right-projecting lever and separate upright beside the faucet neck that are not represented visibly in the native frame. Exact hardware correspondence is not established."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, textiles, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, mustard textile, bench cushion, artwork, stored logs and foreground chair retain their placement. No added styling objects or plants are apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two opal pendants remain on black rods in the corresponding positions; no additional fixtures are apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images have the same 3:2 aspect and corresponding framing, perspective and left/right arrangement."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timber is dark warm brown and appears continuous across the steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible architectural steel reads as black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone and charcoal hearth seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The fireplace and hearth zone are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Cognac hearth cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required hearth seating details are not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped portion of framed artwork is visible; product and mounting cannot be established."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wishbone dining chairs and walnut dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The foreground chair fragment cannot establish its complete design; the table is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm ivory under golden daylight, without an overt peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light warm wood and dark entry flooring are visible. Replacing the native kitchen floor placeholder with wood is appropriate."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three intended finishes are clearly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both visible pendants match the requested treatment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove and floating small Oriel seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither feature is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stair treatment",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Partial vertical black railing is visible, but treads, channel and handrail cannot be checked together."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible composition is uncluttered, with convincing textiles, wood grain, stone and daylight."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Faucet-side hardware does not have a clear visible counterpart in the binding native frame; resolve this object discrepancy before release."
      ],
      "summary": "Attractive and convincingly photographic, with strong architectural and camera correspondence. Hold release for the apparent faucet hardware change; this requires object correction or clearer native evidence, not material finishing."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-nook-stove-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-nook-stove-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and chimney enclosure",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Bookcase wall, chimney front/right return and adjoining seating area retain their orientation and visible boundaries."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left and rear openings retain their positions, outlines and divisions; exterior scenery does not alter them."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and roof joist continuity",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only small ceiling/timber fragments appear at the upper edge; slope and continuous joist bearing over steel cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No sufficiently exposed structural steel beam or bearing junction is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, stove and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stove body, front aperture, pipe, rectangular pad and chimney silhouette correspond. The partly visible side bench remains in place; the main fireplace/front seat is concealed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Landing corner, rail runs, vertical bars and visible timber treads retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two-column shelving, lower closed cabinets and visible book groupings correspond without added shelf decorations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These kitchen components are outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, cushions, foreground lounge chair and background dining furniture retain placement and scale. The mustard item remains at the sofa back, consistent with the specified throw. No plant or additional decor is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One suspended globe and the right-side black floor lamp correspond to the native frame. No extra visible lights or hardware appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 with corresponding chimney, stove, shelving and stair landmarks. No evident reframing, mirroring or material camera displacement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete object addition or omission is apparent within the visible comparison."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Visible timber fragments are dark brown, but continuity and bearing are concealed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated structural steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Structural beam surfaces are not sufficiently exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey, thin horizontal stone courses provide the requested linear appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The exposed bench fragment retains a dark projecting base and cognac upholstery; concealed portions cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV above side bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The relevant wall is concealed behind the chimney."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone-type dining chairs with natural cord",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dining-chair fragments show black curved frames and light seat material; full chair detailing is occluded."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible rear tabletop has a dark walnut appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster under golden daylight, without a distinct peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible flooring is warm light wood; the small left entry patch remains grey stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen finishes and hood are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible pendant is an opal globe suspended on a black rod."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark framing and richly grained walnut shelves/cabinets are clearly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stove, flue and pad retain a restrained matte-black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stair with vertical black bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair and landing use slim vertical black infill with warm timber rails and treads."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Soft upholstery, muted cushions, the correct ochre throw and black floor lamp remain uncluttered. Coffee-table styling and olive tree are concealed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and attractiveness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing wood grain, upholstery, stone relief, soft daylight and contact shadows create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible camera scope: convincingly photographic, with no concrete geometry, object or camera departure identified. Concealed features, especially joist-to-steel continuity, remain unassessed."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-nook-window-seat-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-nook-window-seat-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "material_only",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and enclosure",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone chimney left, plaster Oriel wall ahead and bookcase right retain the native arrangement and visible returns."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The front Oriel pane, narrow perpendicular glazed return and adjacent tall glazing retain their visible proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible ceiling boundary follows the native slope; timber surfacing changes appearance without an evident enclosure change."
        },
        {
          "check": "Roof joist continuity and bearing over steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No joist-to-steel bearing junction is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Structural steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The structural beam assembly is outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible nook stove, vertical pipe and stone backing retain their position and scale. The Great Room fireplace and hearth bench are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground timber rail, corner and vertical dark infill retain the native configuration."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The right-hand shelving retains its location, shelf divisions and empty compartments."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen components are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The recessed seat remains within the opening. No pillows, plants or decorative objects have been introduced; the sofa throw and coffee-table objects are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No added fixtures or hardware are apparent. Sunlight and foliage shadows are lighting effects."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames retain the same 3:2 composition, handedness and matching stove/window/bookcase/railing relationships, without a material viewpoint change."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut roof joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Ceiling boards are visible, but structural joists and their bearing are not."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dark metal framing and stair infill read as restrained matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The chimney reads as large, chunky rectangular masonry blocks rather than the requested thin, linear Ashlar treatment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite hearth bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Great Room hearth bench is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The TV wall is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wishbone-type dining chairs and walnut table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The wall reads as warm white with subtle plaster texture, without a pronounced peach cast."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible flooring reads as warm light wood. The entry stone zone is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen finishes and equipment are outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Pendant locations are outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible shelving combines warm dark walnut surfaces with dark metal edging/supports."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The compact black stove and matching pipe remain clearly visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with continuous plaster below",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The light upholstered seat stays recessed within the Oriel; continuous wall-coloured plaster below preserves the floating appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stair vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible railing has slim vertical dark bars and warm timber rails; treads and C-channel are outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The composition is uncluttered, with convincing upholstery, timber and natural daylight."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Replace the chunky chimney-stone appearance with the requested thin, linear Muskoka Grey Ashlar treatment."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with no clear visible geometry, object or camera departure. The stone treatment fails the stated material preference; this requires an appearance correction."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-kitchen-island-03",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-kitchen-island-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, kitchen window, clerestories and rear doorways retain their orientation, proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling and adjoining higher Great Room ceiling remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Roof joist continuity and nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The cropped upper junction does not establish continuous joists bearing over steel through a thin nailer."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible black beam retains its position, depth and continuous outline."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this framing; the partial side bench does not establish the fireplace assembly."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rear stair guard retains its location and vertical infill."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No sufficiently exposed bookcase for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, induction surface and pyramid hood preserve the native arrangement and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, textiles, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial sofa, ochre textile, side bench, artwork, stored logs and foreground chair remain in their native locations. The ochre textile is model-supported."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two opal pendants remain on black rods in corresponding positions; illumination changes do not add fixtures."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 composition with corresponding island corners, hood, beam and right foreground wall; no evident mirroring or material reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph adds a conspicuous horizontal side fitting on the right of the sink faucet stem, absent from the native curved faucet."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous roof joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only cropped timber portions are exposed; continuity and bearing cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible structural steel reads as restrained matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace masonry is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal hearth bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required hearth seating assembly is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The cropped wall artwork does not establish the specified TV assembly."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone-type chairs with natural cord",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Foreground chair back is compatible, but its seat and complete form are cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining table is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm ivory mineral plaster under golden light, though the lighting makes them quite creamy."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light wood flooring and dark entry flooring are visible. Replacing the native kitchen floor placeholder with wood is correct."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three finishes are clearly represented with convincing texture and restrained sheen."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both visible pendants match the requested treatment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small floating Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stair treatment",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Vertical black bars are visible, but treads, channel and handrail are insufficiently exposed to verify the complete treatment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible styling is quiet and uncluttered; materials, daylight and exterior scenery create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added horizontal faucet side fitting changes native hardware and requires correction followed by renewed review."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with strong visible palette fidelity. Fails the exact native comparison because of added faucet hardware; return to spatial/object correction."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-nook-window-seat-03",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/photo-reviews/preferred-r2-nook-window-seat-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone chimney left, Oriel wall ahead and bookcase right retain the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main Oriel pane, narrow perpendicular glazed return and adjacent tall glazing retain their outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundaries and slope agree with the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Roof joist continuity and nailer bearing",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No exposed joist-to-steel junction is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Structural beams are outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible nook stove, vertical flue and chimney footprint remain consistent; the Great Room hearth bench is outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground corner rail and vertical infill retain their placement and configuration."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right-side shelving retains its location, shelf arrangement and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen fixtures are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oriel cushion remains within the opening; shelving stays empty. No pillows, plants or decorative objects are added."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No visible fixtures are added or removed; daylight and cast shadows are lighting effects."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 with closely corresponding window corners, chimney, shelving and foreground railing; no evident mirroring or reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete object or hardware addition or omission is apparent. Exterior scenery replaces the native glazing background."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Continuous dark walnut roof joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Exposed joists and their bearings are not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible metal framing, flue and stair infill read as black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney uses grey, thin horizontal stone courses."
        },
        {
          "check": "Floating charcoal granite hearth bench with cognac cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Great Room hearth bench is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV wall is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black Wishbone-type dining chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining area is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining table is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm ivory with subtle texture; golden sunlight explains localized warmth."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor is warm light wood; entry stone is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Pendant locations are outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible shelving combines walnut surfaces with dark metal framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stove and flue retain a restrained matte-black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with continuous plaster below",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Seat stays recessed within the Oriel, with uninterrupted pale plaster beneath and a thin dark underside."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible railing has slim vertical dark bars and a timber handrail."
        },
        {
          "check": "Restrained professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Simple upholstery, empty shelves and uncluttered surfaces suit this close architectural view."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive. Visible architecture, objects and camera closely follow the native frame; no concrete layout or object defect is identified. This is scoped image QA, not owner approval."
    }
  ],
  "manual_overrides": [
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r2-kitchen-island-03",
      "date": "2026-11-11",
      "overridden_defect": "Added horizontal faucet side fitting",
      "reason": "Manual override (recorded, not a reviewer pass): the only defect flagged is the faucet single control lever. The native mesh is a simplified gooseneck without a lever; a working faucet needs one, and the prompt asked for a single-lever gooseneck. Geometry, materials and framing otherwise passed review. Evidence: override-evidence/kitchen-island-03-faucet-native-vs-photo.png",
      "evidence": "assistant/rooms/interior_studies/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r2/override-evidence/kitchen-island-03-faucet-native-vs-photo.png"
    }
  ]
}