{
  "date": "2026-11-11",
  "status": "research_draft_not_owner_approval",
  "question": "Is a freestanding black powder-coated steel box bench (66 W x 20.7 D x 16 H in, 3/16 in steel top, open bays storing split firewood, removable CAL 117 wool velvet cushion) viable on the floor-level stone hearth extension of a site-built masonry Rumford fireplace with a raised firebox (sill 25 in above finished floor; opening about 34 in W x 37 in H; hearth about 27 in deep from chimney face x about 67 in wide), set 0.8 in from the chimney face directly below the opening? What are the code limits?",
  "inputs_assumed": {
    "firebox_floor_above_hearth_mm": 635,
    "firebox_floor_above_hearth_in": 25,
    "opening_width_in": 34,
    "opening_width_mm": 864,
    "opening_height_in": 37,
    "opening_area_m2": 0.81,
    "hearth_depth_from_chimney_face_in": 27,
    "hearth_depth_from_chimney_face_mm": 686,
    "hearth_width_in": 67,
    "hearth_width_mm": 1702,
    "bench_front_from_chimney_face_in": 21.5,
    "bench_top_below_firebox_sill_in": 9,
    "notes": "Assumes the hearth extension surface is flush with the finished floor, the opening is flush with the chimney face (the facing), and the hearth is roughly centred on the opening (opening Y372.6-406.6, centre Y389.6). Hearth position in Y was not checked against the model."
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "title": "2024 Building Code Compendium (Ontario), Division B Part 9 - Housing and Small Buildings, Section 9.22 Fireplaces",
      "url": "https://www.ontario.ca/document/2024-building-code-compendium/part-9-housing-and-small-buildings",
      "section": "9.22.1.1, 9.22.1.4, 9.22.4.1, 9.22.5.1, 9.22.5.2, 9.22.8.1, 9.22.9.1, 9.22.10",
      "finding": "Full Section 9.22 text read from the official Ontario compendium page (downloaded 2026-11-11). 9.22.1.1: the Section applies to 'masonry fireplaces constructed on-site'. 9.22.5.1(1): noncombustible hearth 'not less than 400 mm in front of the fireplace opening measured from the facing' and 200 mm beyond each side. 9.22.5.1(2): where the fire chamber floor is 'elevated more than 150 mm above the hearth', the perpendicular dimension increases by 50 mm (elevation 150-300 mm) plus 'an additional 25 mm for every 50 mm' above 300 mm. 9.22.5.2(2): hearth may sit on a combustible floor where the opening is raised at least 200 mm and CSA A405 Clauses 5.3.6.5-5.3.6.7 are followed. 9.22.9.1: no combustible material 'on or near the face' within 150 mm of the opening; projecting (>38 mm) material at least 300 mm above the top of the opening. 9.22.4.1: back of fire chamber to plane of opening at least 300 mm. 9.22.1.4 (Ontario-specific (0.1)-(0.6)): every solid-fuel fireplace needs outdoor combustion air via a damped 100 mm duct whose interior outlet is as close as possible to the opening and ember-protected. 9.22.8.1: factory-built fireplaces follow CAN/ULC-S610 instead. No provision addresses furniture, cushions or firewood storage."
    },
    {
      "title": "2024 Building Code Compendium - Preface (Ontario)",
      "url": "https://www.ontario.ca/document/2024-building-code-compendium/preface",
      "section": "Preface",
      "finding": "O. Reg. 163/24 (the 2024 Building Code) adopts the 2020 National Building Code with Ontario amendments, is 'effective January 1, 2025' and supersedes the 2012 Building Code (O. Reg. 332/12). Which edition governs this permit depends on the permit application date and transition rules (not verified here)."
    },
    {
      "title": "O. Reg. 332/12 (2012 Building Code) on e-Laws",
      "url": "https://www.ontario.ca/laws/regulation/120332",
      "section": "Division B, 9.22",
      "finding": "Page is script-rendered and could not be read by the research tools; the 2012 text was not directly verified. The NBC-based 2012-era text (BC Building Code 2012, below) contains the same 400/200 mm, 150 mm elevation and 150/300 mm clearance rules, so the numeric outcome is expected to be the same, but the Ontario 2024 phrase 'measured from the facing' was not confirmed in the 2012 OBC."
    },
    {
      "title": "Vancouver Building By-law 2019, Division B Section 9.22 (NBC 2015-based text)",
      "url": "https://free.bcpublications.ca/civix/document/id/public/vbbl2019/329427878",
      "section": "9.22.4.1, 9.22.5.1, 9.22.5.2, 9.22.8.1, 9.22.9.1",
      "finding": "National-model wording identical in substance to the Ontario 2024 text (without the Ontario 'measured from the facing' phrase and without Ontario's 9.22.1.4 (0.1)-(0.6) combustion-air sentences). Confirms Canadian Part 9 has no larger hearth for openings over 0.55 m2; that threshold is a US rule."
    },
    {
      "title": "BC Building Code 2012, Division B Section 9.22 (NBC 2010-based text)",
      "url": "https://free.bcpublications.ca/civix/document/id/public/bcbc2012/ep001029.22",
      "section": "9.22.5.1, 9.22.9.1",
      "finding": "Same hearth-extension and clearance numbers as above in the 2010 national-model generation; supports that the 2012 OBC is expected to match."
    },
    {
      "title": "NRC Intent Statement, NBC 2015 Sentence 9.22.5.1.(2)",
      "url": "https://codes-guides.nrc.ca/IA/15NBC/intents-intentions/i004087.2-eng.html",
      "section": "9.22.5.1(2) intent",
      "finding": "Purpose of the deeper hearth for raised fire chambers: to limit the probability that burning embers expelled from the fire chamber reach floor surfaces (and ignite them). Indicates the hearth's job is to receive embers - the zone the bench would occupy."
    },
    {
      "title": "Office of the Fire Marshal and Emergency Management (Ontario), Heating Fire Safety info sheet (as hosted by Town of Tiny)",
      "url": "https://www.tiny.ca/sites/default/files/2025-09/Info%20Sheet%20-%20Heating%20Fire%20Safety%20January%202026.pdf",
      "section": "How do I prevent a heating fire?",
      "finding": "Ontario fire-service guidance: 'Always use a fire screen around the fireplace.' Ashes cooled and put in a lidded metal container kept outside. CO alarm required on every floor in homes with a fireplace. Advisory, not a construction requirement."
    },
    {
      "title": "NFPA Heating safety tips (NFPA-branded sheet, Michigan LARA copy)",
      "url": "https://www.michigan.gov/documents/lara/NFPA._Heating_safety_tips._7._2019._MIPLogo._ECS._Final__663826_7.pdf",
      "section": "Heating safety tips",
      "finding": "Public-education guidance (not code): keep anything that can burn at least three feet (one metre) from heating equipment including fireplaces; use a sturdy screen. Several Ontario municipal fire departments repeat the 1 m / 3 ft guidance (e.g. Hamilton, Guelph winter fire safety pages)."
    },
    {
      "title": "City of Hamilton Fire Department - Winter Fire Safety",
      "url": "https://hamilton.ca/home-neighbourhood/emergency-services/fire-department/fire-prevention/winter-fire-safety",
      "section": "Fireplaces",
      "finding": "Ontario municipal fire-service page cited by search results for 'Always use a fire screen around the fireplace' and keeping combustibles away; page body not fully readable by the tool, so treat as corroborating only."
    },
    {
      "title": "US comparison (informational only): IRC R1001.10 / NFPA 211 hearth extension",
      "url": "https://www.jaspector.com/wiki/hearth-extension/",
      "section": "IRC R1001.10",
      "finding": "US model codes require 16 in front / 8 in sides, increased to 20 in front / 12 in sides when the opening is 6 sq ft (0.55 m2) or larger. Not Ontario law. This opening (about 0.81 m2) would need 20/12 in under US rules; the 27/~16.5 in hearth also satisfies that. Secondary source; NFPA 211 and IRC text not read directly."
    }
  ],
  "requirements": [
    {
      "rule": "OBC 2024 Div B 9.22.1.1 (scope) and 9.22.8.1 (factory-built)",
      "applies_how": "A site-built masonry Rumford is governed by Section 9.22 (or by CSA A405 / an alternative solution if its proportions depart from 9.22). A factory-built or kit Rumford-style unit would instead be governed by CAN/ULC-S610 and its listing/manual, which then sets hearth size and combustible clearances.",
      "numbers": "n/a"
    },
    {
      "rule": "OBC 2024 Div B 9.22.5.1(1) hearth extension",
      "applies_how": "Noncombustible hearth required in front of and beside the opening, measured from the facing.",
      "numbers": "Front >= 400 mm (15.7 in); each side >= 200 mm (7.9 in) beyond the opening. Required width = 864 + 2 x 200 = 1264 mm (49.8 in); provided about 1702 mm (67 in), i.e. about 419 mm (16.5 in) per side if centred - complies if centred."
    },
    {
      "rule": "OBC 2024 Div B 9.22.5.1(2) raised fire chamber floor",
      "applies_how": "Raising the firebox makes the required hearth DEEPER, not shallower (embers fall farther out). Applies here because the fire chamber floor is 635 mm above the hearth.",
      "numbers": "Increase = 50 mm + 25 mm per 50 mm above 300 mm. Elevation 635 mm: 335 mm above 300 = 6 full steps (6.7). Required depth = 400 + 50 + 150 = 600 mm (23.6 in) counting full steps, or 625 mm (24.6 in) if the partial step is counted (conservative). Provided about 686 mm (27 in) from the chimney face: complies with 61-86 mm (2.4-3.4 in) margin, assuming the opening plane is at the chimney face."
    },
    {
      "rule": "OBC 2024 Div B 9.22.5.2 hearth support",
      "applies_how": "Fire chamber floor and hearth on a reinforced concrete slab (>= 100 mm at supports, >= 50 mm at a cantilevered edge), unless the opening is raised >= 200 mm (it is, 635 mm) in which case the hearth may rest on a combustible floor if CSA A405 Clauses 5.3.6.5-5.3.6.7 are met. Separately, the very heavy steel bench plus firewood is a concentrated load on the stone hearth/floor that the structural design should account for.",
      "numbers": "100 mm / 50 mm slab; 200 mm raised-opening exemption threshold."
    },
    {
      "rule": "OBC 2024 Div B 9.22.9.1 clearance to the fireplace opening",
      "applies_how": "Written for combustible construction (trim, mantels) on or near the fireplace face. A movable cushion is not construction, but the same number is a sensible floor: keep any combustible at least 150 mm from the opening edge. The bench top is 229 mm (9 in) below the sill; a cushion thicker than about 3 in would bring fabric within about 150 mm of the opening sill.",
      "numbers": "No combustible within 150 mm (5.9 in) of the opening; projecting combustibles (>38 mm) at least 300 mm (11.8 in) above the top of the opening."
    },
    {
      "rule": "OBC 2024 Div B 9.22.4.1 fire chamber depth (Rumford check)",
      "applies_how": "Rumfords are shallow; Part 9 requires a minimum depth regardless of style. Confirm the specified Rumford meets it or is accepted under CSA A405 / an alternative solution.",
      "numbers": "Back of fire chamber to plane of opening >= 300 mm (11.8 in). A classic Rumford at about 1/3 of a 34 in width (about 11.3 in) would fall short; many modern Rumford kits are deeper."
    },
    {
      "rule": "OBC 2024 Div B 9.22.1.4 (0.1)-(0.6) Ontario combustion air",
      "applies_how": "Every solid-fuel fireplace needs an outdoor-air duct whose interior outlet is as close as possible to the opening and protected from embers. The bench must not cover or block that outlet if it is placed on or near the hearth/face.",
      "numbers": "Duct >= 100 mm diameter or equivalent; tight damper operable from the room."
    },
    {
      "rule": "Fire-service guidance (OFM Ontario; NFPA public education; Ontario municipal fire departments)",
      "applies_how": "Not a building-code rule and not enforceable for furnishings in a single-family dwelling in the way construction rules are, but it is the standard of care insurers and fire services cite. Firewood and fabric directly below an open raised firebox are inside the commonly cited zone.",
      "numbers": "Keep anything that can burn at least 1 m (3 ft) from the fireplace; always use a fire screen; ashes in a lidded metal container outside."
    }
  ],
  "analysis": "Building code: The hearth extension as described appears to satisfy OBC 9.22.5.1 even with the 25 in raised firebox (requires about 600-625 mm deep and 1264 mm wide; provided about 686 x 1702 mm), subject to confirming the facing plane and that the hearth is centred. The Ontario Building Code regulates the construction of the fireplace (hearth size, noncombustible material, clearances of combustible construction) and does not regulate movable furniture or firewood placed on the hearth; nothing in 9.22 prohibits a freestanding steel bench there, and steel is noncombustible. However the purpose of the extra hearth depth for a raised firebox (NRC intent for 9.22.5.1(2)) is to give falling and popping embers a clear noncombustible landing zone, and the bench would occupy about 21.5 in of the 27 in hearth directly under the opening. Fire-service guidance (OFM, NFPA, Ontario municipal fire departments) is to keep anything that can burn about 1 m / 3 ft away and always use a screen. Hazard specifics: (1) Rumfords are shallow and tall and are known to throw sparks into the room more than deeper fireboxes; with the sill 25 in up, embers and any rolled log will drop about 9 in onto the bench top. The 3/16 in steel top will catch them without igniting, but it conducts heat to whatever is underneath, and the 0.8 in gap at the chimney face is an ember trap that drops directly down behind/into the firewood bays. (2) Line-of-sight radiant heat onto the bench top is limited because the top sits below the sill plane, which helps. (3) Split firewood below the top is fuel stored in the ember zone; dry seasoned wood plus bark/debris can be ignited by an ember entering an open bay or the rear gap. (4) A CAL 117 wool velvet cushion meets a smoulder/open-flame upholstery test, which is not ember- or radiant-heat-proof; wool is comparatively ember-resistant but still combustible and must not be on the bench while a fire is burning or embers are live. (5) A raised opening means a conventional freestanding hearth screen cannot stand on the hearth in front of the opening while the bench is there; the screen must sit on the firebox sill, hang from the face (mesh curtain) or be a door system rated for the fireplace. (6) Ontario 9.22.1.4 requires the outdoor combustion-air outlet near the opening; the bench must not block it. (7) The bench must be movable for chimney sweeping, ash removal and hearth cleaning despite its weight. Insurers are not bound by the building code and may treat stored firewood at the hearth as a housekeeping hazard; this was not checked with the owner's insurer.",
  "verdict": "Viable with conditions. The bench itself (noncombustible steel on a noncombustible hearth) is not prohibited by the Ontario Building Code, and the hearth extension as dimensioned appears to meet 9.22.5.1 for a 25 in raised firebox. Storing firewood in open bays directly under the opening and leaving a fabric cushion on the bench while burning are not advisable; they conflict with fire-service guidance and the ember-zone purpose of the hearth. Use the bench as a steel ledge/seat with the cushion off and the firewood either enclosed or relocated whenever a fire is burning.",
  "conditions": [
    "Cushion removed and stored at least 1 m (3 ft) from the opening whenever a fire is lit or embers/ashes are still live; nothing combustible left on the bench top during a fire.",
    "A fire screen used every burn: a face-mounted mesh curtain, a screen that sits on the raised firebox sill, or glass/mesh doors suitable for a Rumford. A freestanding floor screen cannot work with the bench in place.",
    "Close the 0.8 in rear gap with an integral steel back lip or full steel back panel so embers cannot drop behind or into the wood bays; alternatively increase the gap and keep it clear.",
    "Prefer firewood bays with a solid steel back and sides and only a front opening, ideally with a small air gap or second steel sheet under the 3/16 in top so heat from an ember or a rolled log is not conducted straight into the wood; keep only a small day-supply of dry split wood, no kindling, paper, bark debris or fire-starters in the bays.",
    "Consider a removable steel front panel or mesh for the bays during burning, or move the wood to a holder outside the 1 m zone for long or unattended fires.",
    "Bench top no higher than its current 16 in (9 in below the sill); keep any cushion thin enough that fabric stays more than 150 mm (6 in) below the opening sill (9.22.9.1 number used as a floor).",
    "Keep at least the remaining 5.5 in hearth strip in front of the bench clear and noncombustible; no rug overlapping the hearth.",
    "Do not block the Ontario-required outdoor combustion-air outlet (9.22.1.4) or any ash dump/cleanout; the bench must be movable (e.g. steel or felt-free glides or a two-person lift plan) for sweeping, inspection and ash removal.",
    "Bench and loaded firewood weight added to the hearth/floor structural design.",
    "Never used with the fire unattended; ashes to a lidded metal container outside; CO and smoke alarms as required."
  ],
  "must_confirm_with": [
    "Nada (designer): which Building Code edition governs the permit (2012 O. Reg. 332/12 vs 2024 O. Reg. 163/24, by permit application date and transition rules).",
    "Nada: the facing plane from which the 400 mm (+ elevation increase) is measured, the actual hearth depth from that plane, and that the 67 in hearth is centred so each side gives at least 200 mm beyond the 34 in opening.",
    "Nada / mason: the Rumford's fire chamber depth (>= 300 mm, 9.22.4.1), smoke chamber slope (9.22.7.1) and damper (9.22.6.1), or that it is designed to CSA A405 or as an alternative solution; and whether the unit is truly site-built masonry or a factory-built/kit system governed by CAN/ULC-S610 and its listing.",
    "Nada / mason: hearth support under 9.22.5.2 (concrete slab, or combustible-floor support via the 200 mm raised-opening exemption with CSA A405 Clauses 5.3.6.5-5.3.6.7), including the added bench and firewood load.",
    "Nada: location of the Ontario 9.22.1.4 outdoor combustion-air outlet relative to the bench footprint; screen/door mounting provisions on the face or sill.",
    "Muskoka Lakes building inspector: that a freestanding steel bench on the hearth extension is furniture outside the permit scope and does not reduce the required noncombustible hearth; confirm the measured hearth dimensions at framing/final inspection.",
    "Owner's home insurer (by Chris, not the agent): any condition on firewood storage at the hearth for a wood-burning fireplace."
  ],
  "uncertainties": [
    "The 2012 OBC (O. Reg. 332/12) Section 9.22 text could not be read directly from e-Laws; the conclusions use the 2024 Ontario compendium text, which matches the national-model text for these numbers.",
    "Whether the 2024 or 2012 code applies to this permit was not determined.",
    "Rounding of the partial 50 mm elevation step in 9.22.5.1(2) is not stated in the code; both the 600 mm and conservative 625 mm results are given. Both are met by about 686 mm.",
    "Hearth position relative to the opening (centring in model Y) and whether the opening plane coincides with the chimney face were assumed, not checked against the drawings.",
    "Whether the specified Rumford meets the 300 mm fire-chamber depth was not checked; classic Rumford proportions for a 34 in opening could be about 11.3 in deep.",
    "No Ontario Fire Code provision specifically governing furniture or firewood placement near a fireplace in a single dwelling was located; the 1 m / 3 ft figure is public-education guidance, not a cited regulation.",
    "NFPA 211 and IRC text were not read directly; US figures are from a secondary source and are informational only.",
    "Surface temperature of the 3/16 in steel top under ember or rolled-log exposure, and conducted heat to firewood beneath, were not calculated or tested."
  ],
  "not_legal_advice": true
}
