{
  "reviews": [
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, clerestory banks, divided kitchen window and rear glazed doors retain their orientation and broad proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping timber ceiling and continuous joist runs across the steel remain recognizable; no new boxed grid or dropped ceiling."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams and nailer",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both prominent black steel members retain their paths and junctions. Thin bearing detail remains visually subordinate."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Chimney, aperture and bench broadly match, but the firewood has been regenerated into numerous round-ended logs rather than retaining the native split pieces."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Coffee bar, wall-mounted art display and capped half wall remain, with no slatted screen or easel. However, a conspicuous upright bar faucet appears where the native frame shows no corresponding raised silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "This framing does not expose enough of these components to verify them."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet banks, island, open stool recess, stool and hood chimney retain their broad locations. Pendants obscure much of the hood canopy."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Dining chair backs are reshaped into curved upholstered shells instead of preserving the native separate back-pad geometry. Sofa, lounge chairs, throw, coffee-table books and bowl remain broadly placed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three globe pendants, two chimney sconces and the two visible tiny ceiling lights remain in corresponding locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with matching handedness and closely corresponding architectural framing; no major viewpoint change is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The raised coffee-bar faucet and altered chair/firewood forms prevent an unchanged-object pass."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stained timber runs remain continuous and distinct from the lighter ceiling."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed architectural steel reads as consistent black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Linear grey stone reproduces the supplied study character; its recognizable pattern is acceptable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Black frame and muted fabric cushion/bolsters are plausible, but many log ends read as round cross-sections rather than split firewood."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "A thin framed landscape display sits above the Option B bar; exact product identity is not visually provable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible chairs lack the required distinct floating back pad and sculpted walnut articulation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut top is visible, but legs and identifying construction are cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug reads as muted olive woven melange without a mustard field; faint pattern is subdued."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible lounge chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rust-cognac leather lounge seating remains in the native position."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Closed walnut frontage and open recess with a backless cognac-seat stool remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall walnut storage remains at the rear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain tiny rather than becoming large pot lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster with restrained texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood continues into the kitchen, correctly replacing its placeholder; dark entry flooring remains."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible finishes agree; canopy shape is partly obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three convincing opal globes hang on dark stems."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient coverage."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, upholstery, wood and glass create an attractive professionally styled interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Round-ended firewood replaces split pieces.",
        "Dining chair geometry does not preserve the separate floating back pads.",
        "Coffee-bar faucet introduces a raised hardware silhouette absent from the native frame."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing, but object and hardware changes prevent release. Return to spatial/object correction and renewed review; this is not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-b-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-b-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, clerestories, rear glazed doorway and kitchen window retain their orientation, principal proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling slope and visible continuous timber runs are preserved; no boxed beam grid or conspicuous joist break appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The prominent black beam and visible timber/steel relationships remain consistent with the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney outline, raised aperture, cushioned box bench and split-firewood bays retain their principal geometry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar, small sink, wall-mounted art display and capped half wall remain present. No right-side built-in seat, easel or slatted screen is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is concealed from this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The left bookcase retains its location, shelving arrangement and broadly corresponding contents."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, open stool home, adjacent closed front, tall pantry and cropped pyramid hood remain in their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph adds a prominent dark charcoal pillow at the left end of the sofa back that is absent from the native frame. The ochre throw, coffee-table books and bowl are legitimate retained objects."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe pendant, chimney sconces and tiny ceiling pin-light retain their locations; no conspicuous extra light is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Freestanding stove and hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Behind the half wall, the photograph introduces a conspicuous black vertical flue and changes the simplified native stove assembly. This exceeds surface finishing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 composition with corresponding chimney, sofa, beam and island landmarks; no mirror reversal or major reframing is evident."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers are dark walnut and architectural steel reads black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The linear grey masonry reproduces the supplied native study pattern appropriately."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark metal bays contain split cut ends; cushion and bolsters read as warm grey-olive fabric rather than leather or granite."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The framed landscape above the bar provides the required art-mode appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible foreground chairs have broad continuous-looking back panels rather than clearly separate floating upholstered back pads."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped tabletop edge is visible; its base cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The rug is mottled olive-sage with restrained darker grid lines and no ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The chair has oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The right lounge chair reads as warm rust-brown leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The left table and chairs are too cropped to verify their bases, identities and complete count."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The open home contains a backless walnut stool with cognac seat; adjoining closed walnut cabinetry and tall pantry remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible ceiling light is tiny; no large pot lights appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm ivory plaster under warm daylight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light wood continues into the kitchen and dark stone marks the rear entry zone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Cabinetry and hood agree, but the island top reads as grey, strongly veined stone rather than quiet olive stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible pendant is an opal globe on a dark suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible bookcase has dark framing and walnut shelves."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "A black stove is visible, although its added flue fails native-object fidelity."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel seat is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp and no plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears indoors."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added dark sofa pillow.",
        "Added prominent stove flue and changed stove assembly.",
        "Foreground dining-chair backs do not clearly match the specified floating-pad design.",
        "Island countertop shifts from olive to grey veined stone."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, but object changes prevent acceptance. Correct the pillow and stove assembly against the native frame, then renew review; also restore the specified chair details and olive countertop appearance."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-b-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-b-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "material_only",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall returns, rear window, right glazed opening and visible frame divisions correspond to the native."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and their junctions remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joist bearing connections are outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible overhead member retains its position and silhouette; its finish fails separately."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney edge, cropped aperture, cushioned bench and split-firewood bays retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Four walnut fronts, olive counter, small sink/tap, bowl and vessel remain; framed art-mode TV stays above. Extended capped half wall is retained without slats or an easel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not shown in this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Main kitchen components are outside the frame; rear cabinetry remains consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, cushions and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible bench cushion/bolster, cropped armchair, framed display and countertop objects retain their count, placement and approximate scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible chimney sconce remains in place; no additional fixtures appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images are 3:2 with corresponding landmarks and occlusions; no material reframing or mirroring is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete object or hardware addition or omission is apparent. Landscape imagery and exterior scenery provide photographic surface detail."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Roof joists and bearing detail are not exposed sufficiently."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The overhead member has conspicuous brown wood grain and reads as stained timber rather than black powder-coated steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey coursed stone reproduces the native study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible black box framing, split cut ends and warm grey-olive textile cushion/bolster agree; upholstery does not read as leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Thin framed landscape display remains above the coffee bar; exact product identity cannot be verified visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs and walnut Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a small rug fragment is visible, insufficient to assess its overall field and grid."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cropped chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust swivel, Saarinen game table and Moller chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not shown sufficiently."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black pin-lights and opal pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These fixtures are outside the crop; no large pot lights were introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster under golden illumination."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both floor materials and their boundary remain visible and appropriate."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut and olive coffee bar",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut fronts, quiet olive stone and restrained black hardware are convincingly rendered."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen palette and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Main kitchen is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases, freestanding stove and small Oriel seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither is introduced into the interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Overhead steel member is rendered with a brown wood-grain finish."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractively styled, with no evident layout or camera departure. Correct the overhead steel finish to black powder coat before passing."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall returns, central doorway, clerestory divisions and kitchen glazing retain the native arrangement and apparent proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping timber ceiling and continuous joists over the steel remain consistent; no segmented or boxed joists introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both prominent black beams retain their positions, depths and junction."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, raised opening, front bench, cushion, bolsters and firewood bays retain the native composition."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar and olive top remain beneath framed art-mode TV; capped half wall remains. No side seating bench, easel or slatted screen added."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient visible detail to verify their complete geometry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, open stool recess, adjacent closed front, tall pantry and partly obscured hood retain their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, lounge chairs, dining furniture, pillows, throw, coffee-table books and bowls retain their apparent count and placement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph introduces several illuminated recessed fixtures across the flat kitchen ceiling that are absent from the native frame. The three globe pendants and two visible timber-ceiling pin-lights otherwise correspond."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use the same 3:2 composition with closely corresponding chimney, beam, doorway and pendant landmarks; no evident reversal or significant reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Added kitchen-ceiling lights violate the exact native object inventory."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Continuous dark walnut joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stained continuous timbers and consistent black steel are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear ashlar reproduces the supplied native study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth box, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark metal storage frame contains irregular split ends; cushion and bolsters read as muted grey-olive textile rather than leather or stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape is mounted above the coffee bar; appearance alone cannot verify its manufacturer."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chairs retain sculpted wood frames, cognac seats and separate floating back pads."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut tabletop is visible, but legs are cropped or obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug reads as muted olive woven melange with restrained lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290 and rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oak plank-arm olive chair and rust leather lounge chair remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Open recess contains a backless wood stool with cognac seat; adjacent closed walnut front and tall pantry remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible recessed fixtures are small and discreet, although their added count fails geometry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under golden daylight, without a dominant peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light wood continues into the kitchen and dark entry flooring remains visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Palette corresponds; stainless chimney and portions of the hood are visible behind the pendants."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly glowing opal globes retain black suspensions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases, freestanding stove and small Oriel seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These nook elements cannot be assessed from this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Authorized ochre throw and coffee-table styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ochre sofa throw, books and stoneware bowl are correctly retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, material texture, upholstery and restrained styling produce an attractive interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Several recessed lights were added to the flat kitchen ceiling."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing and largely faithful, but added kitchen ceiling lights require spatial correction and renewed review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, boarded wall, entry screen and kitchen retain their relative orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, rear doorway and divided kitchen window remain consistent with the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling planes and continuous timber runs over the steel remain visually consistent; the thin nailer is not clearly resolved."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Large cross-room beam and diagonal foreground member retain their positions and profiles."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Main envelopes remain consistent, but the under-bench split firewood has been replaced largely by round-ended logs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel and lounge chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No built-in bench appears right of the chimney. Boarding reaches the floor; the art-mode TV remains on a black tripod beside the small cognac chair."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair construction is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No bookcase is sufficiently exposed for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet banks, island, open stool recess, stool and hood chimney retain their locations. Pendant occlusion limits inspection of the hood canopy."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Principal furniture and visible tabletop objects remain in their native locations. The ochre sofa throw is correctly retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible globe pendants, two chimney sconces and tiny ceiling lights correspond to the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both views use a consistent 3:2 composition with matching major landmarks and no apparent mirroring or substantial camera shift."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The firewood pieces change from split sections to predominantly round log ends."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Timbers read as dark walnut-stained wood and retain continuous runs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed structural steel reads consistently black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Linear grey stone reproduces the supplied study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Upholstery reads as muted grey-olive fabric, but round logs violate the split-firewood requirement; the heavy steel box construction is insufficiently legible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape display appears on the required black easel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible chairs have broad conventional leather backs; the specified separate floating back pads and sculpted walnut construction are not convincingly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut tabletop is visible, but legs and identifying construction are cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed rug reads as muted olive melange with faint lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chair retains light oak plank arms and olive cushions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Central lounge chair reads as rust-cognac leather in the native position."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Glass-side game grouping is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Closed walnut front and adjacent open recess with a backless cognac-seat stool are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall walnut cabinet bank remains visible beside the entry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain small and restrained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under golden daylight, with subtle surface texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood extends into the kitchen and dark entry flooring remains visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible finishes agree; the pyramid canopy is substantially obscured by globes."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Smooth opal globes with black suspension replace the native faceted appearance appropriately."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases cannot be assessed in this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Under-bench firewood changes to predominantly round logs rather than split sections with cut ends outward.",
        "Dining chairs do not convincingly express the specified Finn Juhl 46 floating back-pad construction."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographic, attractive and broadly faithful to the native composition, but fails for changed firewood geometry and incorrect dining-chair detailing. Correct these objects and renew review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-b-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-b-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, clerestories, sliding glazing, jambs and pane divisions retain the native arrangement and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and dark timber runs agree; no introduced joist break. Exact bearing and thin nailer detail are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black beam positions, depths and intersections remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Opening, chimney silhouette, projecting cushioned box bench and firewood bays retain their native locations and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar, olive top, small sink, stoneware and wall-mounted art-mode TV remain right of the chimney. Capped half wall is retained; no side bench, easel or slatted screen is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair construction is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Left bookcase footprint, shelf arrangement and visible contents correspond."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, closed/open island bays, single stool and cropped hood retain their native positions and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sofa, lounge chairs, dining fragments, game-table fragment, cushions, coffee-table books and bowl correspond. The ochre throw is correctly retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe pendant, paired chimney sconces and tiny ceiling pin-light remain in corresponding positions; no additional fixture is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use the same 3:2 composition with consistent chimney, beam, glazing and furniture landmarks; no material reframing or mirroring is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear object, plant, decor or hardware addition/removal is evident. Exterior scenery replaces the native glazing placeholder."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers read as dark stained wood and remain continuous."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed beams and metal frames read consistently black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney preserves the selected linear stone pattern with convincing relief."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black box frame contains outward-facing split wood; cushion and bolsters read as warm grey-olive textile rather than leather or granite."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape display remains mounted above the coffee bar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chair portions retain walnut framing, cognac seats and separate padded backs; full sculptural profiles are cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient table and leg coverage to assess the complete design."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Mottled olive-sage field and faint darker grid are retained without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oak plank arms and olive upholstery remain legible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right lounge chair retains its warm brown-rust leather appearance and native form."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only cropped fragments appear at the left edge."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One closed walnut bay and one open bay with a backless walnut/cognac stool remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall walnut cabinetry remains full height in the visible kitchen context."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling light is tiny; no large pot lights appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as softly textured warm white under golden daylight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood flooring is consistent across visible living/kitchen areas, with the darker entry zone retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible finishes agree; the stainless hood is partially cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe has an opal finish and black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left shelving reads as walnut with dark framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seat is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears inside the room."
        },
        {
          "check": "Professional photographic presentation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing upholstery, wood grain, stone relief, reflections and daylight produce an attractive professionally styled interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible camera view. No concrete geometry, object or camera departure is evident. Hidden components and exact structural bearing details remain unverified."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-b-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-b-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Wall arrangement is retained, but the narrow rear window gains visible horizontal divisions absent from the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists and steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling and black beam broadly align. This crop cannot establish joist continuity over the steel or the thin nailer connection."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney, cropped opening, steel storage bench, split wood, cushion and bolster retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and extended half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Four-front bar, sink, wall-mounted art-mode screen and capped half wall remain present. No side bench, easel or slatted screen is added."
        },
        {
          "check": "Hardware and countertop objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The native angular bar faucet becomes a curved gooseneck. The shallow bowl and two upright vessels retain their general placement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The kitchen assembly is outside this view; rear storage cannot establish kitchen completeness."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, cushions and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible storage-bench upholstery, split firewood, cropped oak armchair and rug retain their general positions and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible chimney sconce remains in place; no additional fixture is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Same landscape aspect and handedness, with broadly corresponding chimney, bar, partition and doorway framing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No complete joist-to-steel bearing connection is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible beam, bench frame and opening frames read black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey coursed stone reproduces the native study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black box frame, outward-facing split ends and grey-olive textile cushion/bolster are convincingly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Thin framed landscape display occupies the native screen location above the bar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 chairs and Nyhavn dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible fragment is olive melange with darker grid lines and no ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cropped chair shows oak plank arms and olive upholstery; full chair details are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust swivel, Saarinen game table and Moller chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required kitchen features are outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pin-light is clearly discernible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read warm off-white with subtle surface texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both finishes and their transition are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Coffee-bar finishes agree, but the kitchen and hood are not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No bookcase is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove and small Oriel seat with two bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook features are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Rear window gains horizontal divisions.",
        "Bar faucet changes from angular to curved."
      ],
      "summary": "Attractive and convincingly photographic, with strong material and styling fidelity. Window divisions and faucet geometry change, so this requires spatial correction and renewed review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, clerestories, rear glazed doors and kitchen window retain their orientation, placement and principal divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling profile and visible timber runs agree; no new break or boxed beam grid appears. Concealed bearing details cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The large black beam and visible supporting members retain their positions and profiles."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Chimney, aperture and bench arrangement agree, but many angular split firewood ends become round log sections in the photograph."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, chair and screen",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No right-side built-in bench appears. Timber reaches the floor; the tripod TV, small cognac chair and slatted screen remain in their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible left bookcase retains its shelf arrangement and principal book, vessel and artwork groupings."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, closed stool-home door, open stool bay, tall walnut bank and cropped hood remain consistent. Hidden appliance and cabinet details are unassessable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Principal furniture locations and scale agree. Sofa pillows, coffee-table books and bowl remain; the ochre throw is correctly retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lights and additional objects",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe pendant, paired chimney sconces and tiny ceiling light retain their locations. No added plant, floor lamp or conspicuous fixture appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 with matching handedness and closely corresponding chimney, beam, doorway and furniture landmarks; no substantial camera change is evident."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers are dark walnut and continuous; architectural steel reads black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear ashlar appearance and the selected native stone pattern are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench with split wood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The black box is retained, but numerous circular log ends replace the required split firewood."
        },
        {
          "check": "Grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The cushion and bolsters read as muted grey-olive fabric rather than leather or granite."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The framed landscape display sits on the black tripod easel in the specified position."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible foreground chairs have broad, largely rectangular leather backs; the sculpted walnut structure and distinctly floating back pads are not convincingly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped walnut tabletop edge is visible; its legs and identifying construction are hidden."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The rug reads as mottled olive-sage with subdued darker grid lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The olive upholstered chair retains light oak framing and broad plank arms."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The right lounge chair reads as warm rust-cognac leather in its native location."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The far-left table and chairs are too cropped to establish these designs or the complete pair."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One closed walnut bay and one open bay with a backless cognac-seat stool are visible, alongside tall walnut cabinetry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible recessed ceiling point remains tiny; no large pot lights appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm off-white mineral finish; sunlight does not turn the underlying finish distinctly peach."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood continues into the kitchen, and the dark entry floor zone remains visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinets and counters match the palette; the cropped stainless hood retains its sloping canopy."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible pendant is an opal globe on a black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible bookcase reads as dark framing with warm walnut shelving."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The nook stove is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel seat is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the interior."
        },
        {
          "check": "Professional photographic quality",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, textured upholstery, wood grain and restrained styling produce an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Split firewood has changed into numerous round log sections beneath the hearth cushion.",
        "Visible dining chairs do not convincingly express the requested Finn Juhl 46 sculpted frame and floating back pad."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing, with strong camera and room correspondence. Reject for changed firewood geometry; correct it before renewed finishing. Dining-chair design also needs correction against the requested preference."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and visible openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, board wall, slatted screen, hall window and right doorway retain their relative orientation, opening divisions and approximate proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible hall ceiling planes and junctions follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "This crop does not show the joist bearing assembly."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The overhead member retains its visible location and outline; its changed finish is assessed separately."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible aperture, stone perimeter, bench, bolster and firewood storage remain in their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A wall, TV, easel and lounge chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Board wall reaches the floor without a built-in bench. TV remains on a black tripod easel beside one cognac lounge chair."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither is assessable in this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The kitchen is outside the frame; hall cabinetry cannot establish kitchen compliance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, textiles and decor placement",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The rug extends substantially farther into the visible floor than in the native frame. Its upper visible corner moves from approximately 56% across/98% down to 65% across/88% down, despite otherwise closely aligned architecture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible chimney sconce retains its location; no additional fixtures are evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images are 3:2 and preserve handedness and closely corresponding architectural framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear object addition or omission is visible. Landscape art on the TV is consistent with art mode."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Roof joists are outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The native black overhead beam above the slatted screen becomes visibly brown wood-grained material."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear ashlar character is retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Heavy black steel hearth bench and split firewood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark box construction and outward-facing split wood ends remain visible; no granite bench substitution is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Upholstery reads as textured grey-olive fabric rather than leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Slim framed landscape artwork remains on the black easel; exact product identity is not visually verifiable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs and walnut Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug reads as muted olive-sage melange without a mustard field; placement fails separately."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial foreground chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The visible cognac walnut lounge chair does not establish the separate swivel chair."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pin-lights are discernible; no large pot lights were added."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white with subtle surface texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both floor materials and their transition remain legible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Rug footprint or placement changes substantially relative to the native frame.",
        "Overhead black steel member is finished as brown wood."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, but fails native fidelity because the rug moves or expands. Restore its native footprint and the overhead beam's black steel finish, then review again. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-03",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall handedness, clerestory divisions, rear doorway and kitchen window divisions remain consistent with the native."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling planes and visible timber courses follow the native; no additional joist break is apparent over the steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both prominent black beams retain their locations, direction and overall profiles."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney outline, raised opening and long upholstered firewood bench retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar, olive top, small sink, stoneware, wall-mounted art display and capped half wall remain; no slatted screen or easel is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These are outside the useful visible coverage of this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinetry, island, stool homes and pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, open stool recess, stool and tall rear storage retain their locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen hood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The exposed chimney is noticeably narrower and its left edge moves right relative to the native; the visible canopy silhouette also changes behind the pendants."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, lounge chairs, dining arrangement, bowl, cushions and ochre throw broadly retain their positions and scale. No plant or floor lamp appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible globe pendants, two chimney sconces and the visible ceiling pin-lights retain their positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images have a 3:2 aspect ratio, matching handedness and closely corresponding major architectural and pendant landmarks."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The hood's changed geometry prevents an unchanged-object pass. Small obscured hardware cannot be fully assessed."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stained timber and continuous visible members read clearly."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed beams have a consistent black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The selected linear stone pattern is retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth bench with split firewood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Black framing remains, but numerous stored pieces read as round log ends rather than consistently split firewood with cut ends outward."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Muted grey-olive upholstery reads as soft fabric rather than leather or granite."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "A slim framed landscape display occupies the specified wood wall; exact product identity is not visually verifiable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible chairs read as generic cognac upholstered chairs; the distinctive sculpted walnut structure and separate floating back-pad construction are insufficiently expressed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut tabletop is visible, but the identifying leg construction is cropped or obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug areas are muted olive with subdued linear texture; no mustard field appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The oak chair retains plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The central lounge chair reads as warm rust-brown leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The game arrangement is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One open recess contains a backless walnut stool with a cognac seat; adjacent walnut frontage remains closed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall walnut storage remains visible behind the living area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain small and discreet, without large pot lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as softly textured warm white under warm lighting."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light wood flooring and a dark entry floor zone are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The requested palette is present, although the hood geometry fails the native comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly glowing opal globes hang on dark stems."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No assessable bookcase is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The nook stove is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel seat is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and professional styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing fabric, leather, timber and glass responses create an attractive, professionally styled interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Hood chimney and canopy silhouette drift from the native geometry.",
        "Firewood includes conspicuously round log ends.",
        "Dining chairs do not convincingly express the specified Finn Juhl 46 construction."
      ],
      "summary": "Attractive and convincingly photographic, with Option B largely preserved. Return the hood discrepancy to spatial correction, then renew comparison; refine split firewood and dining-chair fidelity."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-hearth-bench-storage-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-hearth-bench-storage-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and visible recess",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone wall, recessed opening, sill and right return retain their orientation, proportions and placement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Exterior opening count, size and division",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No exterior window or door is sufficiently visible to assess."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists, nailer and steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These elements are outside this close view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace/chimney/hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible masonry, black box bench, three firewood bays, projecting base plate, cushion and two bolsters preserve the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV/easel and adjacent wall",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The option's TV, easel and floor-reaching board wall are outside the frame; the framed picture cannot establish TV compliance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair, bookcases and kitchen components",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not shown in this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, upholstery and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One chair, one framed image, bench cushion and two bolsters remain in their native positions and comparable scale. Upholstery seams and wood-end detail are photographic refinements."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures and added objects",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No fixtures, plants, hardware or additional decor have been introduced. Dappled sunlight is lighting rather than an added object."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both retain the same 3:2 close perspective, near-left bolster, receding bench, masonry recess and right-hand chair without evident material camera drift or mirroring."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black structural steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Roof framing and structural beams are outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey textured rectangular masonry follows the native selected stone pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench and split firewood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Heavy black metal enclosure and three bays remain; split cut ends face outward without a stack of round logs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Olive-grey upholstery has a soft velvet nap, fabric seams and two matching bolsters; it reads as fabric rather than leather or granite."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV on Studio Stand",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No identifiable TV or tripod stand is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl chairs and Nyhavn dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug is mottled olive-sage with subdued darker grid lines and no ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "GE 290, rust swivel and game-table seating",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The cropped walnut/cognac lounge chair does not establish any of these specific furniture requirements."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut lounge chair with cognac leather",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One compact timber lounge chair with cognac leather remains at the right."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes, pantry and kitchen finishes",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny pin-lights and opal pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No ceiling fixtures are shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible plaster reads as warm off-white under golden light, with restrained surface texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor is warm light wood; entry stone is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases, freestanding stove and small Oriel seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These features are not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the visible scene."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this close view. The photograph convincingly preserves the visible native geometry and camera while providing attractive, realistic velvet, leather, stone and split-wood detail. Unseen room features and installation clearances are not verified."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-b-03",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-b-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, coffee-bar wall, rear doorway, narrow window and right-hand glazing retain their orientation, approximate proportions and visible divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists and steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The visible overhead black beam is retained. This crop does not establish roof slope, continuous joists or the thin nailer bearing detail."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney edge, fireplace recess, upholstered bench, bolster and firewood bays correspond to the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and extended half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar, olive countertop, small sink, three countertop vessels, framed art-mode display and capped half wall remain in their native locations. No bench or slatted screen is added right of the chimney."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The complete kitchen arrangement is outside the crop; rear cabinetry alone cannot verify these features."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, cushions, decor and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible bench, bolster, split firewood, foreground chair and cabinet hardware retain their approximate count, placement and scale. The framed display changes art content without adding another object."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph adds three recessed ceiling lights across the upper background. None appears in the binding native frame. The existing chimney sconce is retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 landscape frame with consistent perspective, handedness and closely corresponding architectural landmarks."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The three added ceiling fixtures violate the native object inventory."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Individual joists and their bearing connections are not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible overhead steel and bench framing read as dark matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear masonry retains the native study's recognizable block pattern and mineral texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box bench, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible black framing contains split wood with cut ends outward. Cushion and bolster read as muted grey-olive textile rather than leather or granite."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The framed landscape above the bar convincingly reads as an art-mode display; exact product identity cannot be verified visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl dining chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a small rug edge is visible, insufficient to assess its field and grid."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The partial foreground chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust swivel and Saarinen/Moller game setting",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These furnishings are outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Their required configurations cannot be inspected here."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Added ceiling lights read as conventional bright recessed downlights rather than tiny black pin-lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster under golden illumination, without a definite peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The photograph shows light warm timber meeting dark stone at the entry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The coffee bar shows walnut and olive stone, but the kitchen and hood are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pendant locations are included."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove and small Oriel seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither feature is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither is present."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing material detail, soft daylight, upholstery texture and restrained styling create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Three recessed ceiling fixtures are added relative to the exact native frame.",
        "Those fixtures appear larger and brighter than the requested tiny black LED pin-lights."
      ],
      "summary": "Attractive and convincingly photographic, with Option B largely preserved. Fail for added ceiling lights; return to spatial correction and renewed review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-dining-island-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-dining-island-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen rear wall, right cabinet wall and left entry partition retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, entry glazing and divided kitchen window retain their approximate outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundaries and kitchen flat ceiling remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph introduces a row of projecting timber joists beneath the beam at upper left where the native frame shows a smooth ceiling. Their continuity over steel and nailer connection cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The prominent black overhead beam retains its position and broad profile."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel and lounge chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Art-mode screen on a black tripod, board wall extending to the floor, small cognac chair and retained slatted screen are visible; no built-in bench appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not sufficiently exposed for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main cabinet masses, closed and open island bays, single backless stool, tall pantry and partly obscured hood remain in their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows, decor and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table, chairs, sofa, lounge seating and dining bowl retain their arrangement and approximate scale. The ochre throw and coffee-table books/bowl are permitted model contents."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible globe pendants retain their positions. No added large recessed lights are apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 composition with closely corresponding beam, pendant, island and table landmarks; no mirroring or substantial reframing is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Added upper-left timber joists change the visible architectural object inventory."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible added timbers read as warm brown wood, but the required continuous bearing configuration is not demonstrated."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed main beam and visible metal details read as black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Chimney is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Hearth seating and storage are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed artwork display appears on the black tripod stand."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Chairs read as generic straight-framed leather dining chairs; sculpted walnut construction and clearly separate floating back pads are not convincingly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Long walnut tabletop and slender dark supports are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rug reads as mottled olive with a subdued darker grid, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible olive chair has light oak framing and plank-like arms."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Central lounge chair retains cognac-rust leather and its low lounge form."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One closed walnut bay and one open bay with a backless cognac-seat stool are present."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall walnut storage remains visible left of the glazed entry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pin-light detail is sufficiently resolved to verify."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm off-white textured finish; sunlight warms them without a clearly peach material."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light wood continues through the kitchen and dark entry flooring remains visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible finishes follow the requested palette; the stainless hood is partly concealed by pendants."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly luminous opal globes hang from dark stems."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside this composition."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seat is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Professional photographic presentation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, material texture, upholstery and reflections create an attractive, professionally styled interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added upper-left timber joists depart from the binding native frame.",
        "Dining chairs do not convincingly express the requested Finn Juhl 46 design."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographic and attractive, but fails native fidelity because timber joists were added. Return to spatial correction and renewed review; also improve the dining-chair design."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-b-04",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-b-04/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone chimney, wood bar wall, perpendicular half wall and rear entry walls retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rear window, interior passage and right-hand framed opening retain their outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and wall intersections follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joist bearing and full member continuity cannot be inspected in this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The overhead black beam retains its position and visible profile."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible aperture, stone outline, bench, bolster and firewood compartments remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar, small sink, faucet, three countertop vessels, framed display and capped half wall remain in place. No right-side bench, easel or slatted screen appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither is sufficiently exposed for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The main kitchen components are outside this frame; rear cabinetry remains consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground chair, hearth cushion and bolster, split firewood and bar accessories preserve their placement and apparent scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible chimney sconce remains in place; no additional fixtures appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with matching landmark relationships and occlusions; no evident mirroring or material camera drift."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear addition or omission is evident. Landscape imagery supplies the display's art mode; outdoor foliage appears through the existing window."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient exposed joist length or bearing detail."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible overhead steel reads as matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The selected grey ashlar pattern is retained with convincing mineral texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench and split firewood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible bench has a substantial black frame and outward-facing split wood ends."
        },
        {
          "check": "Grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Upholstery reads as muted grey-olive fabric with soft pile, rather than leather or stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The framed landscape reads appropriately as an art-mode display; exact product identity cannot be established visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible portion is muted olive-grey with a faint darker grid, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The kitchen pantry cannot be identified here."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pin-lights are exposed sufficiently to assess."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm white with subtle texture; sunlight adds warmth without an obvious peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both floor materials occupy the native regions and read convincingly."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Main kitchen is outside the crop; the Option B walnut bar and olive stone are consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat and two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears inside the visible room."
        },
        {
          "check": "Professional photographic presentation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Natural directional light, restrained styling, fabric detail and believable wood and stone surfaces create an attractive interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible camera view: convincing photographic finishing with no clear geometry, object or camera departure. Hidden components and joist continuity remain unverified; this is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-kitchen-island-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-kitchen-island-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall returns, kitchen window proportions and divisions, clerestories and left passage agree with the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, joists and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and black beam retain their alignment. Cropped timber portions agree; continuous joist bearing and thin nailer are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The living-room fireplace assembly is outside the frame; the visible chimney is the kitchen hood duct."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, board wall and screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The option-specific wall and TV arrangement cannot be assessed from this kitchen view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left stair guard retains its location and configuration; the stair flight is obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No assessable bookcase appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Island silhouette, closed front panels, open stool recess, tall walnut banks, induction surface and pyramid hood match. Sink, curved faucet and dishwasher remain in their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left seating and recessed island stool retain their placement and scale. No conspicuous added furniture or staging appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both pendants retain their suspension points, relative sizes and positions. No additional ceiling lights appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 composition with corresponding island corners, hood, window and right foreground wall. No evident reframing or reversal."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, hardware, plants and lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete addition or omission is evident among assessable visible components."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous roof joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only cropped timber portions appear; continuity over steel cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible structural beam and stair metal read as restrained black finished steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace masonry is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split firewood and wool velvet cushion",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Hearth seating and storage are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode on Option A easel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV and stand are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Partial left seating does not expose enough detail to establish dining-chair identity."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining table is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Living-room rug is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No identifiable GE 290 appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Cropped cognac seating lacks sufficient detail to verify this specific chair."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Game-table grouping is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Closed walnut front and adjacent open recess with backless walnut stool and cognac seat are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall closed walnut storage banks remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights; no large pot lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No oversized recessed lights have been introduced; individual pin-light details are not discernible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a softly textured warm ivory appearance consistent with warm illumination."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood replaces the kitchen placeholder appropriately; the left entry retains dark stone flooring."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three finishes read clearly and coherently."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two softly glowing opal globes have black stems and ceiling mounts."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat and two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the visible interior."
        },
        {
          "check": "Professional photographic presentation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing wood grain, brushed stainless steel, honed counters, soft plaster texture and daylight produce an attractive architectural photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this kitchen view: convincingly photographic, with no concrete visible geometry, object or camera departure. Living-room and Option A features outside the frame remain unverified."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-04",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-04/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall returns, central doorway, kitchen glazing and clerestory divisions retain their native arrangement and apparent proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping timber ceiling and joist paths remain consistent; no visible joist break is introduced at the steel crossing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main black members retain their positions, depth and intersections."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney outline, raised aperture, front bench, bolsters and firewood bays remain in their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar, small sink, stoneware, wall-mounted art-mode TV and capped half wall are retained. No side seating bench, easel or slatted screen appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The frame does not expose enough of these components for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinetry, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, open stool recess, adjacent closed front, pantry and partly obscured hood retain the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The fireplace sofa's three distinct rectangular back cushions in the native become a largely continuous upholstered back in the photograph, losing the native cushion divisions and count. Other visible furniture and decor remain broadly consistent; the ochre throw is explicitly authorized."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible globe pendants, two chimney sconces and two ceiling pin-lights retain their locations; no additional fixture is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with matching left/right orientation and closely corresponding chimney, beam, doorway and island landmarks."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stained timber and consistent black steel are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The photograph preserves the selected linear stone pattern and grey character."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black bay framing, outward-facing split wood, grey-olive fabric cushion and matching bolsters are visible; upholstery does not read as leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "A thin framed landscape display occupies the specified wall above the bar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible chairs have comparatively straight posts and broad rectangular leather backs; the characteristic sculpted walnut structure and separate floating back pad are not convincingly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut tabletop is visible, but the base is cropped or obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug is olive woven melange with darker grid lines and no ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible lounge chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rust-brown leather lounge seating is retained; swivel hardware is obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The glass-side game setting is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One open recess contains a backless stool with cognac seat; adjacent closed walnut fronts and tall pantry remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Recessed fixtures remain small, dark-rimmed points rather than large pot lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash and warm light wood floor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under sunlight; warm timber flooring continues into the kitchen as authorized."
        },
        {
          "check": "Charcoal stone entry floor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stone flooring is visible through the central circulation area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible surfaces follow the requested palette; the partly obscured hood reads as stainless."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three smooth opal globes hang on dark suspensions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases cannot be assessed in this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, fabric texture, glazing, material variation and restrained styling produce an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Sofa back-cushion divisions and count are lost.",
        "Dining chairs do not convincingly express the specified Finn Juhl 46 design."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing and largely faithful to Option B, but sofa cushion geometry changes prevent a pass. Restore the native cushion arrangement and correct the dining-chair design before renewed review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, two large divided glazing banks, narrow side window and left room connection retain their orientation and general proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping timber ceiling and joists crossing the black steel retain the native arrangement; no obvious joist break is introduced. Thin nailer detail is insufficiently resolved."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main diagonal and crossing black steel members retain their visible positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The visible right bench has newly exposed firewood bays absent from the native silhouette, and its cushion segmentation differs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, chair and screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The area right of the chimney is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No sufficiently exposed stair or bookcase is available for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only the near counter/cabinet corner is visible; the specified kitchen components cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "A large framed landscape is added above the left-room sofa. That sofa's cushion arrangement and several dining-chair forms differ from the native. The authorized ochre throw, coffee-table books and bowl are acceptable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible globe pendants, two chimney sconces and tiny ceiling points retain their general locations; no obvious additional fixture appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 composition with matching handedness and broadly corresponding structural landmarks; no major camera departure is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The added framed artwork alone violates the binding object inventory."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark walnut timber appearance and continuous reading are convincing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible steel has a restrained matte black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney retains grey linear ashlar character."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible storage contains conspicuous round log ends rather than split firewood. Cushion reads as muted grey-olive fabric, but wool velvet and steel construction are not clearly established."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV on Studio Stand",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required option area is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Chairs read as conventional walnut frames with broad wooden backs, without the required separate floating upholstered back pads."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Long walnut top and slim dark legs are visually consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Olive-sage woven melange with faint darker grid; no mustard field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rust-brown leather lounge chair remains in the native location."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Round pedestal table and two slender timber chairs remain by the glazing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside the useful view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain tiny points rather than large pot lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white textured plaster under sunlight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Warm wood floor passes; the entry stone is not exposed sufficiently to verify."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Near walnut cabinetry and muted olive counter are compatible; hood and full kitchen are hidden."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible pendants have opal globes and dark suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added framed artwork above the left-room sofa.",
        "Changed left-sofa cushion arrangement and dining-chair forms.",
        "Right bench storage presentation differs from native and contains round logs.",
        "Dining chairs do not convincingly depict Finn Juhl 46 chairs."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractively lit, but fails binding object fidelity. Return to spatial/object correction before renewed finishing and review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-05",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-05/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, clerestories, kitchen window and rear glazed doors retain their orientation, proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling profile and timber arrangement agree visually; no new timber breaks appear at the black steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Major steel members retain their positions and silhouettes."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, raised aperture, cushion, bolsters and firewood bays retain their visible arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and half wall",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph introduces a conspicuous tall arched faucet over the coffee-bar sink; that raised hardware silhouette is absent from the native frame. TV, bar and capped half wall otherwise correspond; no slatted screen or easel appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient visible coverage for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet banks, island, closed bay and open stool recess retain their arrangement and approximate scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Partial occlusion prevents confirming complete pantry and pyramid-hood geometry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible seating, dining furniture, sofa throw, coffee-table books and bowls broadly retain their native locations and counts."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible globe pendants, two chimney sconces and tiny ceiling pin-lights correspond."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both use the same 3:2 composition with consistent architectural landmarks and handedness."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added objects or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Coffee-bar faucet hardware changes the native object silhouette."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark timber and consistent black steel read clearly."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Linear grey stone follows the supplied study texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth box, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark framed bays contain split cut ends; cushion and bolsters read as grey-olive fabric."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape image occupies the specified wall position."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible backs read as broad leather panels within rectangular timber frames, without the specified distinct floating back pads and sculpted form."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut top is visible, but legs and identifying construction are cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug is muted olive with faint grid lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290 and rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Olive upholstered oak plank-arm seating and cognac-rust lounge seating are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Glass-side game grouping is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Closed walnut bay, open backless stool bay and tall walnut cabinetry are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain tiny points rather than large recessed cans."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under golden daylight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood flooring continues through the kitchen; dark entry flooring remains visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen and olive counters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinetry and stone retain the requested palette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Pendant occlusion prevents verifying the complete hood."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly luminous opal globes retain black suspension hardware."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases; black stove; small Oriel seat and bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These features are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, fabric, wood, stone and reflections create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Coffee-bar faucet silhouette differs from the binding native frame.",
        "Dining chairs do not convincingly express the specified Finn Juhl 46 floating-back design."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing, but fails strict object fidelity because of changed coffee-bar hardware. Dining-chair appearance also misses the requested design."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-nook-window-seat-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-nook-window-seat-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney left, recessed Oriel ahead and bookcase right retain their orientation. Main opening and narrow left glazed return preserve their proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundary retains the native slope; timber finishing changes appearance without an evident enclosure change."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists, nailer and steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The structural bearing junctions are outside this close view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney, black stove and flue retain their locations and proportions. Main Rumford and hearth bench are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A wall, TV/easel, lounge chair and timber screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The option-specific area is outside this camera's coverage."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground timber rail, corner and black vertical infill preserve the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right bookcase shelves, books and leaning artwork retain their visible arrangement; no evident added shelving or decor."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen components are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, cushions and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oriel seat, two cylindrical bolsters and partially visible background chair retain their placement and scale. Upholstery detailing introduces no clear additional object."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and placement",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No assessable fixtures appear in either frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images retain the same 3:2 composition, perspective and landmark relationships, with no material reframing or mirroring."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, plants and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear addition or removal is visible. Exterior scenery and sunlight supply photographic context."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joists and their bearing details are outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible flue, stove, window framing and stair infill read as restrained matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney retains the native selected stone pattern with convincing grey mineral variation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The main hearth bench and storage bays are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV and Studio Stand are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The dining ensemble cannot be assessed from the small background chair fragment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Rug is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290 and rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These seats are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Game-table grouping is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen storage and stools are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights and opal globe pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No lighting fixtures are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as textured warm ivory under golden sunlight, without an evident peach paint finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible flooring reads as warm light wood. Entry stone is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen finishes are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible bookcase combines dark metal detailing with warm walnut shelving."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Matte black stove and vertical flue remain clearly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Recessed upholstered seat retains exactly two olive cylindrical bolsters."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither is added inside the room; trees beyond the glazing are exterior context."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Natural sunlight, glass depth, fabric softness and detailed wood and stone create a convincing, attractive interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this close view: no clear geometry, object or camera departure. Photographic quality is convincing. Option A and most whole-room preferences remain outside the frame and are not verified here."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-nook-stove-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-nook-stove-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, chimney returns, left entrance and rear opening retain their orientation, proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists and steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient ceiling and structural junction coverage to verify slope, continuous members or thin nailer bearings."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stove, chimney and floor plate",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black stove, vertical flue, rectangular floor plate and masonry mass retain their placement and silhouettes."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, lounge chair and screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The relevant option area is outside this frame or concealed by the chimney."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stair opening, railing arrangement, tall shelving grid and lower closed cabinets remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen fixtures",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood cannot be inspected."
        },
        {
          "check": "Visible furniture and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rear sofa, visible cushions, dining furniture and rug retain their general count, placement and scale; no clear furniture addition is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Image 2 adds a conspicuous black cylindrical ceiling spotlight at the upper left, above the entrance area. No corresponding fixture appears in image 1. The rear globe pendant remains in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera and framing",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames retain the 3:2 aspect, handedness and closely corresponding chimney, shelving, stove and stair landmarks."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black structural steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only small ceiling-edge fragments appear; bearing continuity and structural finishes cannot be established."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear ashlar texture and its native pattern are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel hearth bench, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The fireplace-front bench and storage bays are concealed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Frame TV and option-specific stand",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither TV nor easel is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Rear furniture is too obscured to verify the complete chair forms or table legs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug remains olive-sage with subtle darker grid lines and woven variation; no ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "GE 290, rust swivel and game-table seating",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These pieces cannot be identified reliably in this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes, pantry and kitchen finishes",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen components are outside the visible area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The added upper-left cylindrical spotlight is substantially more prominent than a tiny pin-light."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under sunlight, with subtle surface texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood flooring and the visible dark entry-floor patch are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendant",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rear pendant reads as opal glass on a dark suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall bookcase combines dark framing with warm walnut shelves and closed storage."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stove and flue retain a convincing matte black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat and two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No interior floor lamp or plant is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Natural sunlight, textile detail, wood grain and restrained styling create a convincing, attractive interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added black cylindrical ceiling spotlight above the left entrance area."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing and otherwise closely matched, but the added ceiling spotlight fails object fidelity. Correct it and repeat review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-nook-casement-view-a-01",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-nook-casement-view-a-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone wall, white pier, timber reveals and black glazing divisions retain their orientation and general proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and joist runs remain consistent; no new joist break is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible black horizontal members retain their locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a close portion of chimney stone is visible; firebox and hearth cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, lounge chair and screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The option area is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not sufficiently exposed for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Distant kitchen fragments do not establish complete component correspondence."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, pillows, game table, chairs and foreground bolsters retain their general homes and scale. The throw, books and bowl are permitted model details."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and position",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph introduces conspicuous recessed ceiling fixtures, including the disk above the left passage, where the native frame has no corresponding visible fixture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera and framing",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images retain the same aspect, handedness and close view through the casement toward the game table and Great Room."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible joists read as dark stained wood and remain continuous."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed steel and glazing frames read as black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The grey stone preserves the native study's coursed pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Hearth assembly is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl dining chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Distant dining fragments are too occluded to verify."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug reads as mottled olive-sage with restrained darker lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a small foreground chair fragment is exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not identifiable in this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Round game table and two Moller chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Round pedestal table and cognac-upholstered timber chairs remain beside the glass."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required details are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible recessed fixtures read as conventional bright downlight disks rather than tiny black pin-lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls retain a warm off-white plaster appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Visible wood flooring is appropriate; entry stone is not exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is too distant and occluded to verify the complete palette and hood."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two visible globes have opal shades and dark suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the useful view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground seat and olive bolster pair remain, including the glass reflection."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No indoor plant or floor lamp is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing wood grain, upholstery, glass reflections and warm daylight create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added visible recessed ceiling fixtures change the native lighting inventory.",
        "Recessed fixtures are too conspicuous for the requested tiny black pin-light treatment."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing, but fails the exact native comparison because of added ceiling lights. Correct the lighting inventory and repeat review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-05",
      "review_round": "model-facts",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-05-model-facts/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, coffee-bar wall, entry return and kitchen retain their orientation and handedness."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The rear black-framed glazed opening gains a substantial walnut bottom panel/rail in its left section; the native glazing continues down without that opaque wood band."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloped timber ceiling and lower flat kitchen ceiling follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible joists remain continuous at the steel crossing; no new segmented or boxed construction is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Large horizontal beam and diagonal foreground member retain their profiles and positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney perimeter, rectangular firebox, cushioned front bench and firewood bays remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and extended half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar, olive top, small sink, stoneware, wall-mounted art-mode TV and capped half wall are present. No side bench, easel or slatted screen is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "This framing does not expose enough of these components for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, induction surface, open stool recess, adjacent closed front and tall pantry remain consistent. Hood is partly obscured by pendants."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, lounge chairs, dining furniture, bowl, books, bolsters and ochre throw retain their arrangement and approximate scale. The throw is a modelled feature."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Four visible suspended globes, two fireplace sconces and tiny ceiling pin-lights correspond to the native view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera and framing",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with closely corresponding chimney, beam, pendant and island landmarks; no obvious reframing or mirroring."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The added opaque wood band in the rear glazed opening changes its construction."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers are dark walnut and remain continuous."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed architectural steel reads as matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear ashlar follows the supplied study texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth box, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black-lined bays contain outward-facing split ends; cushion and bolsters read as muted grey-olive fabric, without leather sheen or granite supports."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "A thin framed landscape display occupies the specified wall above the bar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining-chair study silhouette",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut frames, cognac seats and separate horizontal back pads faithfully follow the permitted simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut tabletop is visible; legs are cropped or obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug is muted olive-sage with subtle darker lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible lounge chair has oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Central lounge chair reads as warm rust-cognac leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The glass-side game grouping is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One open recess holds a backless walnut stool with cognac seat beside a closed walnut front."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall walnut cabinetry is visible at the rear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain small points rather than large pot lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster under amber daylight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood continues through the kitchen as authorized; dark entry flooring remains visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible finishes match; the stainless hood is partly hidden behind globes."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Smooth glowing opal globes retain black suspensions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seat is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Professional photographic presentation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing upholstery, wood grain, stone, glazing and daylight create an attractive styled interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Rear glazed opening: added walnut bottom panel/rail changes the native opening construction."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographic and attractive, with strong material and furniture fidelity. Correct the rear glazing's added opaque wood band and repeat comparison before release. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-a-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-a-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, boarded TV wall, central doorway, upper glazing and divided kitchen window retain their orientation, arrangement and apparent proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping timber ceiling and joist paths agree with the native frame; no added joist breaks are apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams and bearing detail",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both prominent black steel members retain their depth, direction and junctions. Thin bearing detail has no evident departure at this scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Firebox, chimney outline, cushioned bench and black firewood-bay structure retain their locations and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, chair and screen",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Art-mode TV remains on a black tripod stand, angled toward seating; small cognac chair and elevated timber screen remain. No built-in bench or bar appears beneath the TV."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is outside the useful visible area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcase construction cannot be assessed from this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Island, open stool recess, adjacent closed front, full-height cabinetry and hood chimney retain native positions and scale. Globes obscure much of the hood canopy."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible seating, dining furniture, pillows, bowls and coffee-table books correspond. The ochre sofa throw is an authorized modeled object."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three globe pendants, two chimney sconces and visible tiny recessed lights correspond; no additional fixtures are apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images retain the same landscape aspect, handedness and wide composition, with corresponding beam, chimney, glazing and furniture landmarks."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear unauthorized addition, omission or relocated hardware is visible."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Timbers read as dark stained wood; exposed steel reads consistently black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear masonry reproduces the native study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench and split firewood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible structure reads as black metal with split cut ends facing outward, without a granite bench substitution."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Bench upholstery reads as muted grey-olive textile with soft bolsters, rather than leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Slim framed landscape display remains on the requested easel stand."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining-chair study",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut framing, cognac seats and separate horizontal back pads faithfully follow the permitted simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut tabletop is visible, but the identifying leg construction is cropped out."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed rug areas read as muted olive woven melange with restrained lines; no mustard field appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chair retains warm timber plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rounded cognac-rust leather lounge seating remains in its native position."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs by glass",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "This grouping is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Closed walnut front and open recess with a backless cognac-seat stool remain; tall walnut storage is retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Recessed fixtures remain small points rather than large pot lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster under golden illumination."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood extends into the kitchen as authorized; the darker entry floor zone remains."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinetry and subdued olive-grey counters fit the palette; visible hood metal is stainless, with canopy mostly obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly luminous opal globes retain black suspensions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not sufficiently exposed to judge."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat and two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing upholstery, wood, stone, glass and daylight create an attractive professionally styled interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible view: convincingly photographic, with no clear geometry, object or camera departure. Occluded features remain unverified; this is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, doorways, clerestories and kitchen glazing retain their arrangement and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling profile is retained; visible walnut joists read as continuous members above the black steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible beam locations, depth and connections remain consistent with the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The enclosure and bench match, but several angular split-firewood ends become round or oval log ends, particularly in the right storage bay."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel and chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Board wall reaches the floor without a built-in side bench; tripod TV, small cognac chair and upper timber screen remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient stair geometry is visible to assess."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left shelving, books and decorative objects preserve their overall arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen fixtures and cabinetry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, closed door, open stool home, pantry and cropped hood retain their locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible seating, tables, cushions, bolsters, coffee-table books and bowl remain consistent. The ochre sofa throw is correctly retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sconces, globe pendant and tiny ceiling pin-light retain their locations; no clear added fixture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera and framing",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Same 3:2 aspect, handedness and broadly matching perspective; architectural and furniture landmarks retain their relative framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear object additions or omissions beyond the firewood-shape substitution identified above."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers have dark walnut grain and continuous profiles."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible architectural steel reads consistently black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Linear grey stone reproduces the supplied study texture appropriately."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth box with split firewood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Heavy black storage box is retained, but some wood ends read as unsplit round logs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Grey-olive wool velvet hearth cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Muted grey-olive upholstery reads as soft fabric, with both bolsters retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape artwork appears on the tripod-supported screen."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining-chair massing",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walnut chairs retain cognac seats and separate horizontal back pads consistent with the permitted simplified model."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped table edge is visible; leg design cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Muted olive melange and faint darker grid remain; no mustard field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oak plank arms and olive cushions remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm brown-rust leather lounge chair remains beside the sofa."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The left-edge crop does not expose enough of the set to verify its forms or count."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Closed walnut door and open bay with backless cognac-seat stool are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall walnut cabinetry remains at the rear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible recessed light remains tiny; no large pot lights introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster under golden daylight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm light wood continues into the kitchen; dark entry flooring remains."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible finishes match; hood is partially cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe has an opal appearance and black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible shelving reads as dark framing with walnut shelves."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a narrow fragment of the adjoining seating area is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither is introduced."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Some hearth-storage firewood changes from angular split pieces to round or oval log ends; restore split wedges with cut ends facing outward."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with strong camera and room fidelity. Fails the strict object-preservation check because some stored firewood becomes round logs."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-a-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-a-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, panelled wall, slatted screen, rear window and right doorway retain their orientation and visible divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and overhead black beam retain the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joist bearings are outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible aperture, masonry, cushioned bench and firewood bays retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, chair and screen",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Art-mode TV on black tripod, small cognac chair, floor-reaching board wall and screen remain; no right-side built-in bench appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rug placement and extent",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Native shows only a small rug tip at the bottom centre. The photograph shows a substantial rug area extending upward beside the lounge chair and toward the entry. Its visible footprint differs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Other furniture, decor and lighting",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chairs, bolster and wall sconce retain their count and approximate placement; no plants or floor lamp appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair, bookcases and kitchen components",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components cannot be assessed from this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 with closely corresponding architectural landmarks and unchanged handedness."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joists and bearings are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible beam, easel and bench frame read as black coated metal."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear masonry reproduces the supplied native study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black box bays contain split firewood with cut ends outward; grey-olive cushion and bolster read as soft fabric."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape image appears on the retained tripod stand."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug appearance",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug reads as mottled olive-sage with subtle darker lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial foreground chair retains light oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The visible cognac chair is the separate Option A lounge chair."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and Moller chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen fixtures cannot be identified here."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No recessed lights are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls appear warm white with restrained surface texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both finishes are visibly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat and two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Rug visible footprint changes substantially relative to the binding native frame."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with Option A largely preserved. Fail for changed rug placement or extent; correct the spatial correspondence and review again. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-dining-island-a-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-dining-island-a-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation, openings and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen window, glazed door, solid returns and upper glazing retain their native arrangement and apparent proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling and prominent black beam retain their alignment; no ceiling or beam displacement is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joist bearing and continuity are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth bench, stairs and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, lounge chair and screen",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Art-mode screen on black tripod, small cognac lounge chair, floor-reaching board wall and timber screen remain in their native locations; no built-in bench appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinet banks, island induction, open stool recess, adjacent closed front, tall pantry and partially obscured pyramid hood preserve the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, lounge seating, dining chairs, table, bowl and cushions correspond to the native frame. Chair silhouettes faithfully retain the permitted simplified massing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible suspended globes retain their relative sizes and positions. No additional interior fixture is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use the same landscape aspect and corresponding pendant, bowl, doorway and beam landmarks; no material viewpoint reversal or reframing is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear added or omitted interior object, plant, light or hardware is visible."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous roof joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Roof joists and their bearing detail are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed beam, pendant stems and easel read as black finished metal."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone and specified hearth bench assembly",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Chimney, hearth storage, cushion and bolsters are outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed abstract artwork appears on the black tripod easel in the intended location."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut frames, cognac seats and separate horizontal back pads faithfully reproduce the authorized simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Long walnut tabletop and slender dark supports retain the intended appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug is mottled olive-sage with subdued darker grid lines and no ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chair retains light oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rounded cognac-rust leather lounge seating remains beside the sofa."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Game-table group is outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One open recess contains a backless walnut stool with cognac seat; adjacent closed walnut front and tall pantry remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pin-light is sufficiently resolved to assess; no large pot light appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white mineral plaster under golden daylight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen and dining flooring read as warm light wood; the darker entry-floor area is retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut cabinetry and muted olive counters are convincing; visible hood portions retain stainless appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly luminous opal shades retain black suspension hardware."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases, freestanding stove and small Oriel seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These features and the Oriel bolsters are outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears inside the room."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Leather, woven upholstery, walnut grain and daylight shadows convincingly evoke a professionally photographed interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible view: convincing photographic finish with no clear geometry, object or camera departure. Occluded features remain unassessed; this is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall returns, left connecting opening, narrow window, two tall glazing banks and their principal divisions retain the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloped ceiling and joist directions agree; no introduced joist break is apparent over the black steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Major crossing beams retain their positions, orientation and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph introduces an exposed firewood compartment beneath the right upholstered bench where the native frame shows a closed black base. Its conspicuous round log ends also contradict the required split firewood."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A board wall, TV, tripod easel and small lounge chair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The specified area right of the chimney is outside this framing; its option configuration cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair, bookcases and slatted screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside the frame or obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets and island",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible foreground walnut cabinet retains its location and broad envelope."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stool homes, pantry and pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The relevant kitchen faces and equipment are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and tabletop decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, lounge chairs, dining group, game table and two chairs retain their arrangement. Sofa pillows, dining bowl, coffee-table books and bowl remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible globe pendants, including the cropped left globe, two chimney sconces and tiny ceiling light points retain their approximate positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 composition with matching architectural convergence, foreground cropping and left/right arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The newly exposed log-filled compartment changes the visible bench construction and contents."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark timber and black architectural steel read convincingly; thin nailer detail is not independently resolvable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney retains a grey, horizontally layered stone appearance consistent with the supplied texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The black base and grey-olive textile upholstery are plausible, but the visible storage contains round logs rather than split wood with cut ends outward. The fireplace-front seat is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode on Studio Stand",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV and stand are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut frames, cognac seats and separate horizontal back pads faithfully follow the permitted simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table has a walnut top and slender dark support structure."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rug reads as woven olive-sage melange with faint darker grid lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290 and rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground oak plank-arm chair has olive cushions; adjacent swivel retains cognac-rust leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Round pedestal table and two slender timber chairs remain beside the glazing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required faces are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny pin-lights and opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling points remain tiny; pendants read as illuminated opal globes with dark suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under golden daylight rather than peach paint."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor is warm light timber; the dark adjoining floor area is retained, though the entry stone extent is largely obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walnut cabinet and muted olive-grey counter fit the palette; hood is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No bookcase is sufficiently exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove and small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These nook features are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears inside the room; exterior trees are landscape context."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Right bench gains an exposed log-storage opening absent from the native frame.",
        "Visible firewood presents round logs rather than the required split wood."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with strong overall camera and architectural fidelity. Reject for the changed right-bench storage construction and incorrect firewood; correct and renew review. Option A's TV/easel area cannot be assessed from this view."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-nook-stove-a-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-nook-stove-a-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney faces, left wall/window and right-hand passage retain their orientation, visible boundaries and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists, nailer and steel beams",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only cropped ceiling and timber fragments are shown; bearing details and full member continuity cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and stove hearth",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney mass, corner, black stove, straight flue, glazed front, lower recess and floor plate correspond to the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised fireplace hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The chimney obscures the main fireplace frontage and storage bench."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, lounge chair and slatted screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These option-specific elements are outside this camera's view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible descending treads, black vertical infill, posts and timber handrails retain their arrangement and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The tall bookcase retains its two-column arrangement, four populated shelf levels, lower open compartments and closed base."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The kitchen fixtures are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, cushions, ochre throw, dining furniture and rug remain in corresponding positions. No clear object addition, removal or scale change is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible suspended globe retains its position and black suspension; no additional fixtures appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use the same 3:2 composition, with matching chimney, stove, stair and background relationships and no reversal or material reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, hardware and plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete addition or omission is identifiable within the visible comparison."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Full joists and their bearing connection are cropped out."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair metalwork and bookcase framing read as black coated steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear ashlar courses retain the intended stone character."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The main hearth bench and its contents are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV and stand are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial background chairs retain the native walnut-and-cognac massing; fine sculptural detail is not assessable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a small tabletop portion is visible; legs and complete form are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The rug is woven olive-sage with faint darker grid lines and no ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290 oak, plank arms and olive cushions",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No sufficiently exposed GE 290 is available for assessment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The complete grouping cannot be identified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen cabinetry is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No recessed fixtures are clearly visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white mineral plaster under golden daylight, without a distinct peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible wood flooring has the requested warm light character; the small left entry patch remains dark."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible pendant reads as an opal globe with black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The tall bookcase combines dark walnut surfaces with black framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The stove and straight flue retain the requested black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible view. The photograph preserves the native composition and visible objects while providing convincing materials, daylight and interior styling. Occluded option details and structural connections remain unassessed; this is not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-nook-casement-view-a-02",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-nook-casement-view-a-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone chimney left, white pier, timber-lined casement and right wall retain their orientation. Major frame divisions and opening proportions remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling and beam directions agree. No new joist break is apparent; the thin nailer connection is obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Generated image introduces conspicuous firewood ends in the lower-left bench compartment where the native frame shows an empty dark compartment. Firebox and front hearth are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, lounge chair and timber screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The relevant area right of the chimney is outside or obscured in this tight view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient visible coverage."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen components are outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Visible furniture and tabletop objects",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground bolsters, background sofa, game table and chairs, dining furniture, and coffee-table books/bowl retain their general locations and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two visible suspended globes retain their positions. No conspicuous added ceiling fixtures appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 with matching handedness and closely corresponding chimney, pier, casement and foreground-seat landmarks."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added objects, decor, plants or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The newly visible lower-left firewood changes the native compartment contents."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible timbers read as medium warm brown rather than dark walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible structural steel and window framing read consistently black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear masonry preserves the native study's characteristic pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel hearth bench, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible added logs have round ends rather than split-wood faces. Foreground bolsters have a convincing olive velvet appearance, but the hearth assembly is largely obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only small background fragments are visible; their complete forms and table legs cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug reads as muted olive-sage with subtle darker markings and no mustard field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Identifying plank arms and complete chair form are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No identifiable swivel chair is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Round pedestal table and two walnut/cognac chairs remain by the glass, consistent with the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pin-light detail is sufficiently resolved."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white textured plaster; golden sunlight does not establish a peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible wood floor has the requested warm light tone; entry stone is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globes appear opal with slender dark suspensions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stove is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two foreground olive bolsters retain the native seating arrangement and have convincing textile surfaces."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing textile, stone, timber and plaster detail, coherent reflections and attractive warm daylight give a professionally styled photographic impression."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added lower-left firewood changes native object contents and shows round log ends.",
        "Visible roof timbers are lighter than the requested dark walnut stain."
      ],
      "summary": "Attractive and convincingly photographic, with close camera and architectural correspondence. Added firewood prevents a geometry/object pass; correct the compartment contents and darken the timbers before renewed review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-03",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall returns, clerestories, rear glazed doorway and kitchen window retain their orientation, visible divisions and approximate proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope and continuous roof joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloped timber ceiling and continuous dark joists retain the native arrangement; no new joist break is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main black beam retains its span, depth and position above the kitchen connection."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, raised rectangular opening, cushioned black storage bench and outward-facing split firewood retain the native configuration."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, chair and screen",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tripod-mounted TV, small cognac chair, floor-reaching wood wall and upper slatted screen remain; no built-in side bench or bar is introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is obscured beyond the screen and adjoining walls."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left bookcase retains its shelf arrangement and broadly corresponding books and accessories."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinetry, island, single open stool home, adjacent closed front, tall pantry and cropped hood retain their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sofa, coffee table, lounge chairs and partially cropped dining/game furniture retain their relative placement and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Pillow and decor inventory",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "An upright ivory textured pillow appears beside the rust pillow at the sofa's right end; no corresponding separate ivory pillow is visible in the native frame. The ochre throw, coffee-table books and bowl are correctly retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lights and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe pendant, wall sconces and tiny ceiling light retain their locations; no clear extra fixture or hardware is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 landscape composition with corresponding chimney, beam, sofa and kitchen landmarks and unchanged handedness."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers are dark walnut and architectural steel reads consistently black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear masonry reproduces the supplied native study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Heavy black box, split cut ends and grey-olive fabric cushion with bolsters are visible; upholstery reads as textile."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape artwork appears on the retained black tripod stand."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cropped walnut and cognac chairs preserve the accepted simplified native seat and separate back-pad silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped tabletop is visible; its leg configuration cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rug is mottled olive-sage with faint darker grid lines, without a mustard field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oak plank arms and olive upholstery remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right lounge chair has warm rust-cognac leather and retains its native location."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The left-edge table and chairs are too cropped to verify the complete set or bases."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One stool bay remains open with a backless cognac-seat stool; adjacent walnut closure and tall pantry remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible recessed ceiling point remains tiny, without oversized pot lights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm ivory plaster with subtle texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light wood flooring and dark rear entry floor zone are retained; kitchen wood appropriately replaces the native placeholder."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible kitchen surfaces follow the requested palette; cropped hood reads as stainless."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible pendant is an opal globe suspended from black hardware."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible shelving reads as walnut with dark framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seat is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, textile detail, leather, wood and exterior reflections create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added ivory textured sofa pillow beside the right-end rust pillow changes the native object inventory."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing and largely faithful, but the added ivory sofa pillow prevents an exact object-preservation pass. Correct the inventory and recheck."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-a-03",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-a-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "material_only",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, board wall, screen, rear cabinetry, narrow window and right glazing retain their arrangement and visible divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundaries and slope remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The bearing assembly is outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beam geometry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The overhead member retains its visible location and outline."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible aperture, stone perimeter, cushioned bench and wood bays remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel and chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No right-side built-in bench appears; board wall reaches the floor, with tripod TV and one compact lounge chair."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not exposed sufficiently for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen components are outside this view; rear entry cabinetry remains consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, cushions and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible furniture count, placement and scale remain consistent; TV landscape is appropriate art-mode content."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One chimney sconce remains in the same location; no additional fixtures appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Corresponding edges and furniture occupy consistent positions within matching landscape proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear object addition or omission is visible."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joist continuity and bearing cannot be inspected here."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The overhead member that is black in the native frame reads as brown, wood-grained timber in the photograph."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear ashlar and the selected texture pattern are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth bench, split wood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black box frame, outward-facing split wood, grey-olive fabric cushion and bolster read convincingly."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape artwork appears on the black tripod stand."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl dining chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a small rug fragment is exposed; its pattern cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The visible small chair is the option-specific lounge chair; a swivel cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and Moller chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen storage is outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black pin-lights and opal pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither fixture type is exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under golden sunlight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both finishes are visible and appropriately differentiated."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove and small Oriel seat with two bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Natural sunlight, upholstery, leather, stone and exterior scenery create an attractive, convincingly photographic interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Restore the visible overhead steel member's black powder-coated appearance; it currently reads as wood."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing, with no clear layout or camera departure. Correct the overhead steel material before passing."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-03",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main glazing wall, chimney at right and adjoining nook at left preserve handedness and orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both tall glazing banks, their divisions and the narrow window beside dining remain recognizably consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The sloping timber ceiling retains its overall form."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joists appear continuous, but the thin bearing detail cannot be independently resolved at this distance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The prominent black beams retain their arrangement and visible junction."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Chimney edge and cushioned side seating are visible; the fireplace front and storage bays are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel and lounge chair",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph shows framed art mounted on the nook wall, rather than a visibly freestanding Frame TV on a black tripod stand. The required single lounge-chair arrangement is not established."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Insufficient visible coverage to verify these components."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only the foreground counter and cabinet end are shown; the required kitchen components are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The central sofa loses the native olive and pale pillows, retaining a rust pillow instead. The photograph also places an additional bowl on the dining table although the native bowl is already retained on the coffee table."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible globe pendants, two chimney sconces and small ceiling light points retain their general positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The 3:2 entry view and main architectural framing remain closely consistent; no mirroring is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Changed pillow inventory and the additional dining-table bowl prevent an object-preservation pass. The ochre throw and coffee-table books/bowl are legitimate model contents."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers have a dark walnut appearance and read as continuous members."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed beams read as restrained black coated steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney stone retains a grey linear masonry appearance; the selected texture pattern is acceptable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench with split-firewood bays",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Front bench construction and storage contents cannot be inspected."
        },
        {
          "check": "Grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible side seating reads as muted grey-olive fabric with bolsters, rather than leather."
        },
        {
          "check": "Frame TV in option A",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The visible framed image reads as wall-mounted art; the required angled tripod Studio Stand is absent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut frames, cognac seats and separate horizontal back pads preserve the permitted simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The walnut rectangular top and slim dark legs are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The rug reads as muted olive-sage woven melange with subtle linear divisions and no ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The leather lounge chair retains its warm rust-cognac appearance and placement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Round pedestal table and two timber chairs remain beside the glazing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The relevant island faces are outside the visible area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Pantry is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain tiny points, without large pot-light apertures."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster under warm illumination."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light timber flooring and the foreground charcoal stone strip are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut cabinetry and muted counter are visible, but the hood and complete scheme cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible pendants have opal globes and dark suspension hardware."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are not sufficiently exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stove is obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The complete Oriel seating arrangement is outside the visible coverage."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the photograph."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and attractiveness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing upholstery, timber, glazing and natural light create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Option A's freestanding tripod TV arrangement is not reproduced.",
        "Central sofa pillow inventory changes.",
        "An additional stoneware bowl appears on the dining table."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing, but object and option-specific layout changes prevent acceptance. Return for correction and renewed comparison."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-nook-casement-view-a-03",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-nook-casement-view-a-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone wall left, white pier, timber-framed central opening and right glazing retain their orientation, divisions and relative proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling and beam trajectories agree. No added joint or break is apparent in the exposed timbers; bearing details are partly obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only the near stone face and cropped foreground upholstery are visible; the firebox and bench construction cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A wall, TV easel, lounge chair and slatted screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These option-defining elements are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not sufficiently exposed for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen components are outside the visible frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, cushions, decor and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, foreground bolsters, round table and chairs retain their locations and approximate scale. The ochre throw is an authorized model feature."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two visible suspended globes retain their positions. Tiny ceiling points remain discreet; no large pot lights appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 with matching foreground occlusion, architectural alignment and left-right ordering. No material reframing is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear unauthorized addition or omission is visible. Exterior scenery and richer glass reflections provide photographic finishing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers read as dark stained wood with continuous silhouettes."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible structural steel and framing read black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The near stone face preserves the native selected pattern and grey mineral character."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box hearth bench and split-firewood bays",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bench structure and storage are cropped out."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground upholstery reads as textured olive velvet rather than leather or stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Distant dining chairs are too occluded for reliable identification."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining table and legs are insufficiently exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible rug is olive-sage with subtle grid character; no mustard or ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "A complete identifiable chair is not visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen round game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Round walnut tabletop, dark pedestal and two walnut/cognac chairs remain by the glass."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling light points are tiny and unobtrusive."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls retain warm white plaster character under golden light without reading as peach paint."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor reads as warm light wood. Entry stone is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two visible globes have convincing opal diffusion and thin dark suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not sufficiently visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The complete seat and its bolster arrangement cannot be established from this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the interior."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing material texture, daylight, upholstery and reflections create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible view: no concrete geometry, object or camera departure identified. Hidden option details remain unassessed; this is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-04",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-04/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, clerestories, sliding-door divisions and kitchen glazing retain the native arrangement and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous roof joists and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and beam positions agree. Visible timber members remain continuous; thin nailer detail is not clearly resolvable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Chimney, fireplace and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney outline, raised aperture, front bench and storage envelope match the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel, chair and screen",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No right-side built-in bench appears. Board wall reaches the floor; tripod TV, small cognac chair and upper slatted screen remain correctly placed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Firewood geometry",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph substitutes numerous whole round logs for the native split wedges, particularly across the left and middle storage bays."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair construction is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left bookcase, shelves and contents retain their general placement and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinetry, closed/open island bays, backless stool, tall pantry and partial hood retain native locations and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible seating, tables, pillows, sofa throw, coffee-table books and bowl correspond. No plant or floor lamp is added."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and positions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe pendant, paired chimney sconces and tiny ceiling light correspond; no obvious additional fixture appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use the same 3:2 composition with consistent landmark relationships and no mirroring or material reframing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers are dark walnut brown and architectural steel reads black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear stone preserves the supplied study texture and pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel box hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Storage enclosure reads as a heavy dark metal box rather than granite."
        },
        {
          "check": "Split firewood with cut ends outward",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Cut ends face outward, but many pieces are clearly whole round logs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Muted grey-olive upholstery reads as soft fabric rather than leather; cylindrical bolsters remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape art is displayed on the black tripod easel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walnut and cognac chairs retain the explicitly permitted simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped tabletop edge is visible; its base cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rug reads as mottled olive-sage woven material with subdued darker divisions, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chair has oak plank arms and olive cushions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right lounge chair retains warm rust-brown leather and its native placement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Cropped left-edge furniture does not expose the complete table base or both chairs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Closed walnut bay, open stool bay, cognac stool seat and tall walnut storage are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible recessed light remains tiny; no large pot lights appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read warm off-white under sunlight, with subtle plaster texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood extends into the kitchen as authorized; the entry retains its dark floor zone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible surfaces follow the requested palette; the cropped hood remains stainless."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible pendant is an opal globe on a black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible bookcase reads as walnut shelving with dark framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the visible area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is outside this composition."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and attractiveness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, fabric, leather, wood and exterior depth create an attractive professionally styled interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Whole round logs replace native split firewood in the hearth storage bays; correct their geometry and renew review."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing and broadly faithful to Option A, but fails the explicit split-firewood requirement. Return the log substitution to spatial correction."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-a-04",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-right-of-fireplace-a-04/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, board wall, screen return, rear cabinetry, narrow window and right glazed opening retain their orientation, proportions and visible divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and their junctions follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joist bearing connections are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible overhead black member retains its position and extent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible aperture, masonry boundary, cushioned steel storage bench and bolster preserve the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel and board wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Board wall continues to the floor without a built-in bench; framed TV remains on the black tripod stand in the same location and orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Slatted screen and half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Screen footprint, vertical slats and supporting half wall remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither is sufficiently exposed for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen components are outside the view; rear entry cabinetry remains consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, cushions and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Lounge chair, partial foreground chair, bench cushion, bolster and split firewood retain their placement and approximate scale. Landscape art is consistent with TV art mode."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixtures and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible chimney sconce remains in place. No additional visible fixtures or conspicuous hardware were introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with consistent perspective, cropping and left-right relationships."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No material object addition or omission is apparent within the shared visible frame."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Joists and bearing details are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible beam, bench frame and TV stand read as black finished metal."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear coursing reproduces the native study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel box bench, split firewood and wool velvet",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible bench has a substantial black metal frame, outward-facing split wood ends and grey-olive textured upholstery with a matching bolster."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape artwork reads convincingly as art mode on the retained tripod easel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small walnut and cognac lounge chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single compact chair has a dark wood frame and cognac leather seat and back."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs and Nyhavn table",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a small cropped rug edge is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial foreground chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust swivel, Saarinen table and Moller chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These pieces are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen storage and island are not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights and opal pendants",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These lighting types are not exposed in this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under sunlight, without a distinct peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both materials are clearly visible in the native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Freestanding stove and small Oriel seat with two bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook features are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the visible interior."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Natural sunlight, believable leather and velvet, detailed wood and stone, and restrained styling create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible view: convincing photographic quality with no apparent material geometry, object or camera departure. Hidden features remain unverified; this is not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-04",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-04/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall returns, large left connection, narrow window and both divided lake-glazing banks retain their orientation and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes and timber/steel arrangement correspond; no obvious joist break or displaced beam."
        },
        {
          "check": "Chimney and bench storage",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The right bench's solid black front in the native becomes an open compartment filled with newly visible round logs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A board wall, TV/easel and small lounge chair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The specified area right of the chimney lies outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Not sufficiently shown for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only the near counter corner is visible; the required kitchen components cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and tabletop decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofas, lounge chairs, dining arrangement, game table, pillows, coffee-table books and bowl broadly match native placement and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe pendants, wall sconces and tiny ceiling lights correspond; no obvious added fixture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use the same 3:2 composition with corresponding architectural landmarks and foreground cropping."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The exposed round-log pile and opened storage compartment depart from the visible native bench."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible joists read as dark stained timber and retain continuous members."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed structural steel reads consistently black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney edge retains a grey linear masonry appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel hearth bench, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible storage contains round logs rather than split firewood. The cropped fireplace-front bench cannot otherwise be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV and easel are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut frames, cognac seats and separate horizontal back pads faithfully follow the permitted simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table has a walnut top and slim dark legs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rug reads as woven olive melange with restrained darker lines, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground chair retains oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rust leather lounge chair remains in the native position."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Round pedestal table and two timber chairs remain beside the glass."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside the visible kitchen portion."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain tiny luminous points, without large pot-light apertures; housing finish is not discernible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm ivory plaster under warm daylight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light wood flooring and the dark entry-zone surface remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Near walnut cabinetry and olive counter are visible, but the hood and complete kitchen are not."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible pendants have opal globes and thin black suspensions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat and two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the interior."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, upholstery, wood grain and reflections create an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Right bench front changed into open storage containing round logs absent from the visible native frame.",
        "Round logs violate the explicit split-firewood requirement."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing, with strong camera and architectural correspondence, but the altered bench storage and added round logs require spatial correction and renewed review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-06",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-great-room-wide-b-06/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation, openings and ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls, clerestory divisions, kitchen window, glazed doorway and ceiling planes retain the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Timbers retain their continuous spans and relationship to the black steel. The thin bearing detail is too small to certify independently."
        },
        {
          "check": "Chimney, fireplace and hearth bench",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Main envelopes remain consistent, but the photograph replaces the native angular split firewood with predominantly round log ends."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option B coffee bar, TV and extended half wall",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut bar, olive top, small sink/faucet, stoneware, art-mode screen and capped half wall remain in their native locations. No side bench, easel or slatted screen appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair and bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "This framing does not expose enough of these components for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinetry, induction, open stool recess, adjoining closed front, tall storage and partly obscured hood retain their positions and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and tabletop decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible furniture silhouettes and placements remain consistent. Sofa throw, coffee-table books and bowl are legitimate native objects; simplified dining-chair backs are preserved."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and placement",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globe pendants, chimney sconces and tiny ceiling pin-lights correspond to the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use the same 3:2 composition and consistent architectural landmarks, with no evident mirroring or substantial viewpoint change."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Firewood shape has changed from split pieces to round logs. No other clear object addition or omission is evident."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark stained timbers and consistent black architectural steel are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The photograph retains the supplied linear stone pattern; its repetition is not independently a defect."
        },
        {
          "check": "Heavy black steel hearth bench with split firewood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Black framing remains, but predominantly round log ends contradict the split-firewood requirement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm grey-olive wool velvet cushion and bolsters",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Upholstery reads cream/beige rather than warm grey-olive. Its precise textile cannot be established visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "A slim framed landscape display occupies the specified wall above the coffee bar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut frames and cognac seats/back pads faithfully follow the permitted simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn dining table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut tabletop is visible, but its legs are cropped or concealed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The visible rug reads beige/tan and lacks the requested olive-sage field and faint darker grid."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290 and rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oak plank arms with olive upholstery and the adjacent rust leather chair remain recognizable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The game-table grouping is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Open stool bay with backless cognac-seat stool, adjacent closed walnut front and tall walnut storage are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny black LED pin-lights and opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Recessed lights remain tiny; pendants have convincing opal glass and black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read warm off-white under golden daylight without a clear peach finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood extends into the kitchen as authorized; the dark entry floor zone remains."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible finishes agree; the hood canopy is largely obscured by pendants."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases cannot be assessed in this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove and small Oriel seat with two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These nook components are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears in the visible interior."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, glass reflections, upholstery and joinery produce an attractive professional interior photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Round logs replace required split firewood.",
        "Hearth upholstery reads cream/beige instead of warm grey-olive.",
        "Rug reads beige/tan instead of olive-sage with faint grid lines."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing, with broadly faithful geometry and camera. Fail for changed firewood geometry; correct the rug and hearth upholstery appearance as well. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-05",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-fireplace-hearth-a-05/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, wood wall, entry screen and kitchen retain their relative orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Openings: count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, rear glazed doors and kitchen window retain their openings and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping timber ceiling and lower flat kitchen ceiling follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Continuous roof joists and thin nailer",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Cropped upper members and concealed bearing interfaces prevent checking complete continuity and nailer construction."
        },
        {
          "check": "Steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Large black kitchen-opening beam and visible upper members retain their placement and profiles."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall stone chimney, raised rectangular aperture and black storage bench retain their arrangement, cushion and bolsters."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A TV, easel and chair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood wall reaches the floor without a built-in bench; landscape art-mode display remains on a black tripod beside the small cognac chair. Slatted screen remains above the half wall."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair construction is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Left bookcase retains its shelves and visible books, vessels and framed art without a clear object addition or omission."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walnut cabinetry, tall pantry, island, single occupied stool recess and cropped hood remain in their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sofa, lounge chairs, dining chairs, coffee table, pillows, books and bowl retain their arrangement and scale. Ochre sofa throw is an authorized modeled item."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Paired chimney sconces, visible globe pendant and tiny ceiling light remain in corresponding positions; no clear extra fixture appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use 3:2 composition with consistent perspective, handedness and principal architectural landmarks."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No definite object, plant, fixture or hardware addition/removal is visible."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut joists continuous over steel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Visible timber is dark walnut, but complete joist continuity is cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible architectural steel reads matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey linear ashlar reproduces the supplied native study texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth box, split firewood and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Heavy black box contains outward-facing split wood; grey-olive cushion and bolsters read as soft textile rather than leather or stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Framed landscape display sits on the required black easel stand."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut and cognac chairs faithfully retain the expressly accepted simplified native silhouette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut Nyhavn table with slim black legs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Main dining tabletop and leg system are cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark olive-sage rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rug reads as woven olive melange with subdued darker divisions, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chair has oak plank arms and olive upholstery."
        },
        {
          "check": "Rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rounded cognac-rust leather lounge chair remains beside the sofa."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only cropped portions of the left table and chairs appear; complete identities and count cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible closed walnut front and open recess with backless cognac-seat stool match the requested arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall walnut pantry remains visible behind the seating."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny LED pin-lights",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling light is tiny; no large pot lights appear."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white plaster under warm illumination."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood continues through the kitchen; dark stone remains at the rear entry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible finishes match; hood is partially cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible suspended globe reads as opal glass with black support."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible shelving retains dark framing and walnut shelves."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat and two olive bolsters",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seating is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and styling",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing upholstery, leather, wood, stone, daylight and reflections create an attractive professionally styled interior."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible view: convincingly photographic, with no concrete geometry, object or camera departure identified. Concealed construction and out-of-frame preferences remain unverified; this is not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-05",
      "review_round": "first",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-11-preferred-living-r4/photo-reviews/preferred-r4-entry-arrival-a-05/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation and openings",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall returns, tall glazing banks, mullion divisions, narrow side window and left room connection retain their native positions and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, continuous joists and steel beams",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping ceiling, timber runs and crossing black steel retain the native configuration. No new joist break or doubled member is visible; concealed bearing details cannot be independently assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney and hearth bench",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney edge and cushioned bench retain their placement and silhouette. Firebox and storage bays are outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Option A wall, TV and tripod easel",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The area right of the chimney is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair, bookcases and slatted screen",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These components are outside the frame or concealed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island, stool homes, pantry and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only the foreground counter and cabinet end are visible; their geometry remains consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture, pillows and decor",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sofas, lounge chairs, dining group, game table and two chairs preserve native placement and scale. Visible cushions, coffee-table books and bowl remain consistent; no added staging is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Lighting count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible pendant globes, including the cropped left globe, retain their locations. Tiny ceiling lights and chimney sconces correspond to the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images have a 3:2 aspect ratio and matching architectural intersections, furniture overlaps and edge crops. No material camera shift or mirroring is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear addition, omission or relocation is visible within the shared crop."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut continuous joists and black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Timbers read as dark stained wood; exposed structural steel reads as matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible chimney retains linear grey stone and the native study pattern."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel hearth bench, split firewood bays and wool velvet upholstery",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Grey-olive textured upholstery and bolsters are consistent, but the bench construction and firewood bays cannot be assessed from this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Samsung Frame TV in art mode",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "TV and stand are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Finn Juhl 46 dining chairs and walnut Nyhavn table",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut and cognac chairs faithfully retain the permitted simplified native silhouette; the walnut table has slim dark legs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kasthall Angsmark rug",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rug reads as woven olive-sage melange with restrained grid markings, without an ochre field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Wegner GE 290 and rust leather swivel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground oak plank-arm chair has olive upholstery; adjacent swivel retains rust-brown leather and its native form."
        },
        {
          "check": "Saarinen game table and two Moller 77 chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Round pedestal table and two timber chairs remain beside the glazing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Island stool homes and full-height walnut pantry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Required details are outside the crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Tiny LED pin-lights and opal globe pendants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling lights remain tiny; pendants read as illuminated opal glass with black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls and light wood floor with charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read as warm off-white under sunlight, floors as light warm wood, and the left entry zone retains dark flooring."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Visible walnut cabinet end and olive counter agree; the hood and remaining kitchen are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases, black stove and small Oriel seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "These features are not exposed in this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "No floor lamp or plants",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and attractiveness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing daylight, upholstery texture, wood grain, glass reflections and restrained styling produce a polished architectural photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this visible crop: convincing photographic finishing with no clear geometry, object or camera departure. Concealed and off-frame option details remain unassessed."
    }
  ]
}