{
  "reviews": [
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-great-room-wide-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-great-room-wide-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Fireplace left, entry centrally behind seating, and kitchen right retain the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, central doorway and divided kitchen window retain their apparent boundaries and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping timber ceiling, crossing members and large steel beam follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, raised opening, charcoal front platform and adjacent bench with stored logs retain their visible arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair construction is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither bookcase is sufficiently exposed for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinet masses, island, induction surface, sink and partially obscured chimney hood retain their apparent locations and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofas, glass coffee table, dining table and black chairs correspond to the native arrangement; some chairs are cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph adds small recessed downlights to the rear entry/kitchen ceiling where the native frame shows plain ceiling. Three pendants and fireplace sconces otherwise correspond."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images are 3:2, with consistent handedness, framing and apparent perspective across major architectural landmarks."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Added rear-ceiling downlights violate object preservation. No other clear object addition or removal is apparent."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Timbers have a dark walnut appearance against the warmer ceiling infill."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated exposed steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible structural steel reads black; stair, bookcase and liner finishes cannot all be assessed here."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney shows grey, horizontally coursed textured stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Raised opening and charcoal front platform are visible; exact appliance dimensions are not established by pixels."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls read warm white with subtle mineral texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm timber flooring contrasts with dark entry flooring."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Walnut cabinets and stainless hood are present, but counters read predominantly grey/taupe rather than clearly olive. Hood canopy is partly obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three softly glowing opal pendants hang from black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the assessable view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table and chairs match the requested palette; eight seats cannot be counted in this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel and its underside are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair is outside the frame."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added recessed rear-ceiling lights absent from the binding native frame.",
        "Kitchen counters lose the clearly olive appearance."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with strong overall native-frame correspondence. Fail for added downlights: return to spatial correction and renewed review. Counter colour also needs adjustment. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-fireplace-hearth-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-fireplace-hearth-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, adjoining walls, entry and kitchen retain their orientation and relationships."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, entry glazing and kitchen window retain their openings and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood ceiling planes, dark roof timbers and broad steel beam follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Raised rectangular aperture, full-height chimney, projecting front seat and adjacent bench/log storage remain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left bookcase retains its location, shelf arrangement and extent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, induction surface and cropped pyramid hood retain their placement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two sofas, lounge chair, glass coffee table and visible dining furniture preserve the native arrangement and relative scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two chimney sconces, one visible pendant and the visible recessed light occupy corresponding positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 composition with matching perspective, occlusions and left/right ordering; no material reframing is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete addition or omission is evident. Exterior scenery and surface detail provide photographic finishing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible roof timbers have a dark walnut appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible broad steel beam and firewood liner read black; coating specification cannot be verified visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney reads as grey, horizontally coursed linear ashlar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Raised opening and charcoal seat across the fireplace front are retained; exact appliance identity is not visually established."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm pale, subtly textured finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood flooring contrasts with the charcoal entry floor."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinetry, counters and cropped hood express the requested palette."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible pendant has an opal globe and black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Walnut shelving is visible, but exposed frame material is insufficiently clear to verify black steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table and chairs match the palette; full dimensions and eight-seat count are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this camera view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel and its underside are outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stairs are outside this frame."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with realistic upholstery, wood grain and warm daylight. No concrete geometry, object or camera departure is evident. Pass applies only to visible content and does not establish owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-nook-window-seat-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-nook-window-seat-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone wall left, Oriel wall ahead and bookcase right retain their orientation and intersections."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oriel front glass, narrow glazed return and adjacent tall divided glazing preserve their visible proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundaries agree. Wood texture replaces the plain native surface without an evident shape change; roof beams are outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Freestanding stove, vertical flue and recessed Oriel seat retain their positions and scale. Rumford and its front seat are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground timber rail, corner joint and vertical bars preserve their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right-hand shelving retains its visible shelf levels, depth and position."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No additional freestanding furniture appears; the window seat remains within the recess."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither frame exposes a light fixture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 aspect and matching landmark framing, perspective and left/right order; no evident camera drift."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No evident additions or omissions. Seat upholstery seams, surface textures, daylight and exterior scenery are finishing details."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Ceiling boards are visible, but identifiable structural roof timbers are not."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair bars, bookcase frame and window framing read black; concealed members and firewood liner cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey rectangular stone in horizontal courses gives a credible ashlar appearance; exact product fidelity is unverified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wall reads as softly textured warm white under golden sunlight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor is warm light wood; entry stone is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pendants are shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right-hand shelving reads as walnut with dark framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining area is outside this crop."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black stove and flue are clearly retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below, floating appearance",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Seat stays recessed above continuous wall-coloured plaster, without a projecting timber support box."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible guard has slim vertical black bars and a warm timber rail; channel and treads are cropped out."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive. Visible geometry and camera framing agree with the native reference; no concrete layout or object departure identified. This is scoped visual QA, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-nook-stove-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-nook-stove-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Bookcase wall, chimney front and right return retain their orientation and relationships."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left and dining-area openings retain their outlines; no clear division change."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundaries and cropped right-hand timber remain consistent. Upper-left ceiling receives a wood finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Nook stove, pipe, rectangular pad and chimney mass remain aligned. Main Rumford and front seat are hidden."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stair opening, timber handrails, black posts and vertical infill retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Frames and shelf divisions remain consistent, but the photograph increases and rearranges individual books, visibly in the upper-left shelf bay."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The chimney obscures the kitchen."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, lounge chair, dining table and chairs retain their placement and approximate scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "One dining pendant remains in the same position; its faceted native surface becomes smooth opal glass."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2, with consistent handedness and closely corresponding stove, bookcase, railing and chimney landmarks."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Individual book objects have been added or rearranged. No other definite object or fixture addition is apparent."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The cropped roof timber at upper right reads dark walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair infill, posts and bookcase frames read black; beams and firewood liner are hidden."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Grey colour is plausible, but the chimney reads as chunky rectangular blocks rather than thin linear Ashlar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The main fireplace frontage is behind the chimney."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls have a warm, softly mottled plaster appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm light wood flooring and the darker left entry-floor patch remain visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen walnut, olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen finishes and equipment are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible dining pendant has an opal globe and slender black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible shelving combines black frames with warm walnut shelves and lower cabinetry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table and chairs match the requested palette; all eight seats cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The compact stove and vertical pipe remain black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Slim vertical black bars and warm timber rails/treads are visible."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Book population changes violate the explicit no-added-objects requirement.",
        "Chimney stone is too chunky for the requested linear Ashlar appearance."
      ],
      "summary": "Attractive and convincingly photographic, with close camera and major geometry correspondence. Reject for changed book objects; correct and recheck. Stone appearance also needs refinement. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-kitchen-island-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-kitchen-island-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen rear wall, left circulation openings and right foreground return retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen window, clerestories and visible doorways retain their relative sizes, positions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling, adjacent wood ceiling and diagonal steel/timber boundaries match the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace/chimney/hearth/seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace assembly is outside the frame; only the side bench and log cubby are partially visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left stair opening and vertical railing remain in place; treads and channel are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No identifiable bookcase is exposed in this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets/island/hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Island footprint, induction, cabinet banks, sink, dishwasher and pyramid hood retain their arrangement and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial sofa, foreground black chair and side bench retain their positions and apparent scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two pendants retain their ceiling mounts, black rods and relative heights."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position/framing/aspect/handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images are 3:2; normalized island corners, window boundaries and foreground return align visually without mirroring or evident reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No concrete interior addition or omission is evident. Exterior scenery and surface detail provide photographic finishing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timber reads as dark warm walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed beam, stair bars and pendant rods read black; cubby liner is too shadowed to assess."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Masonry is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace frontage is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls show warm white colour and restrained mineral texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light warm wood and the dark entry circulation zone are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut cabinetry, muted olive honed surfaces and stainless pyramid hood are clearly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both pendants have luminous opal globes and black suspension rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the visible area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only part of one black chair is visible; dining table and full seating cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible railing uses slim vertical black bars; concealed stair components remain unassessed."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with no evident geometry, object or camera departure. Visible preferences are represented; this is a visual comparison, not dimensional certification or owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-entry-arrival-01",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-entry-arrival-01/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "material_only",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Lake glazing, central solid pier, left nook connection and right fireplace wall retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both large glazed banks retain their visible mullions, horizontal divisions and sloping heads; left-side openings remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping timber ceiling, parallel roof timbers and crossing black steel members follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney edge, partial firebox and projecting stone platform retain their placement. The cropped view cannot establish the complete raised-appliance or front-seat arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No assessable stair flight or guard appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcase construction is outside the visible frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible foreground island/cabinet corner retains its footprint and countertop outline. Remaining cabinetry and hood are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two Great Room sofas, lounge chair, glass coffee table, dining set, screen and visible nook seating remain in corresponding positions and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible pendant globes, including the cropped left globe, two ceiling downlights and two chimney sconces retain their locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with corresponding architectural landmarks, foreground cropping and left/right relationships. No material camera drift is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No definite addition or omission is identifiable among clearly resolved visible objects; lighting and reflection changes do not establish object changes."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Roof timbers read as dark walnut brown against the lighter wood ceiling."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible major steel beams read as consistent matte black. Stair, bookcase frames and firewood liner cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The chimney reads as substantial rectangular coursed blocks rather than the requested thin, linear Ashlar Muskoka Grey appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The firebox and platform are too cropped to verify the raised opening and front-only seat."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm ivory tone and subtle plaster-like variation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Light warm flooring contrasts with the dark stone zone at the right foreground."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinetry is dark walnut and the counter reads as muted honed olive. The hood is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globes read as softly glowing opal glass suspended on black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No assessable bookcase is shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The dining table reads as walnut with black chairs in the retained arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The nook stove area is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The projecting seat and its underside are not shown clearly."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The stair is outside the frame."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Chimney stone appears too block-like and insufficiently thin and linear for the requested Ashlar Muskoka Grey finish."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with strong visible geometry and camera correspondence. Revise the chimney stone appearance; no definite spatial correction is identified in this frame."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-great-room-wide-02",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-great-room-wide-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Fireplace left, entry centrally behind seating, kitchen right; handedness is preserved."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, central glazed doorway and divided kitchen window retain their arrangement and approximate proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Sloping wood ceiling, crossing roof timbers and long steel beam follow the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney silhouette, raised rectangular opening, dark front seat and adjacent bench/log storage remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair construction is outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Neither bookcase is sufficiently visible to compare."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinet masses, island, induction surface and chimney remain aligned; pendant occlusion limits canopy inspection."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofas, glass coffee table, dining table and black chairs retain their relative locations and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible pendant globes, two recessed lights and two fireplace sconces correspond to the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with closely corresponding architectural landmarks and foreground cropping."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph adds a large textured area rug beneath the seating and coffee table where the native frame shows exposed wood flooring."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Roof timbers appear dark walnut brown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible architectural steel is black; stair, bookcase frames and liner finish cannot be fully assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney has thin, predominantly grey linear stone courses."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Raised opening and charcoal front seat are visible; exact appliance identity is not verifiable from pixels."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm ivory, softly textured appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood and darker entry paving are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut cabinets, muted olive counters and stainless chimney are present; pyramid canopy is largely obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Smooth luminous opal globes hang from black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the inspectable view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table and chairs match the requested finishes; all eight seats cannot be counted."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel and its seat are outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stairs are outside this camera."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added seating-area rug absent from the binding native frame."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with strong visible palette fidelity. Fail for the added rug: return to spatial correction and renewed review. This is technical QA, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-fireplace-hearth-02",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-fireplace-hearth-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney, adjoining artwork wall, entry and kitchen walls retain their orientation and relationships."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible clerestories, left glazing, entry glazing and kitchen window retain their outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wood ceiling plane, roof timbers and large black crossbeam match the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Raised rectangular opening, full-height chimney, projecting front stone seat and adjoining bench/log storage remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair construction is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Left recessed shelving retains its location, shelf arrangement and empty contents."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible cabinet masses, island, induction surface and cropped hood retain their positions and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two sofas, lounge chair, glass coffee table and visible dining furniture match the native arrangement and relative scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two chimney sconces, visible recessed light and kitchen pendant remain at corresponding locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 aspect ratio with corresponding architectural landmarks, occlusions and edge crops; no reversal or evident reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, lights, decor and hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No evident interior additions or omissions. Exterior foliage and sunlight supply photographic context without changing visible opening geometry."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible timbers have a dark walnut appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible crossbeam and firewood liner read black; stair steel is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney reads as grey, horizontally coursed linear stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Raised opening and charcoal front-only seat are retained. The simplified recess does not establish exact Rumford appliance detailing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm off-white, subtly textured finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor and charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both materials are visible in their native locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walnut cabinetry and subdued olive counters are clear; the visible hood portion reads stainless, with its full shape cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible kitchen pendant has an opal globe and black suspension rod."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible recessed shelving reads walnut with dark framing; detailed frame construction is not resolved."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table and chairs match the requested finishes; the crop cannot verify all eight seats."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this camera's visible area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seat and supporting wall are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stairs are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and attractiveness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing fabric, leather, wood and stone textures, coherent daylight and reflections create an attractive architectural photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "The photograph preserves the visible native geometry and camera convincingly. Visible finishes broadly satisfy the brief. This scoped image review does not certify appliance detailing, hidden features or installation requirements."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-nook-window-seat-02",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-nook-window-seat-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "material_only",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone wall left, Oriel wall ahead and bookcase right retain their orientation and junctions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oriel opening, narrow glazed return and adjacent tall glazing retain their outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundaries agree; wood boarding changes appearance without an evident geometry change. Structural beams are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Freestanding stove, vertical flue, stone backing and Oriel seat retain their locations and proportions. Main Rumford and front seat are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground rail corner and visible vertical infill preserve their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right-hand bookcase retains its shelf levels, depth and cropped placement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Window seat remains within the opening; no additional furniture appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Neither image shows visible light fixtures; none were introduced."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both use a 3:2 frame with closely corresponding window corners, stove, shelves and railing landmarks; no apparent mirroring or reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No evident interior additions or omissions. Exterior scenery and sunlight provide photographic finishing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No distinct structural roof timber is exposed sufficiently to assess its stain."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible railing infill and bookcase metal details read black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey rectangular stone courses provide the requested general ashlar appearance; exact product fidelity is unverified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Main fireplace is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Oriel wall reads distinctly peach/tan rather than warm white, even allowing for warm sunlight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor is warm light wood; entry stone is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No pendants are shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible shelving reads walnut with black metal details."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Left foreground stove and flue read matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Seat remains recessed within the small Oriel, above continuous wall-coloured plaster without a timber support box."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible foreground infill consists of slim vertical black bars with a warm timber rail; channel and treads are not visible."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Visible limewash wall is too peach/tan for the warm white brief."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with no evident geometry or camera departure. Correct the wall colour before passing; this is an appearance correction only."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-nook-stove-02",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-nook-stove-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Bookcase wall, chimney front/right return and adjoining room retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The broad grey background opening behind the dining area becomes a detailed kitchen view with a narrower visible window; original opening divisions are not preserved."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The upper-left ceiling gains visible plank divisions and a recessed light absent from the native frame. Limited ceiling coverage prevents full slope verification."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace/chimney/hearth/seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible nook stove, vertical pipe, floor plate and masonry mass retain their basic configuration. The main Rumford and front seat are hidden."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Descending stair, timber rail and vertical infill retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall shelving, lower closed storage and book groupings remain in corresponding positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets/island/hood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph introduces discernible background base cabinets, faucet and pyramid hood that are not visible as those objects in the binding native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, foreground lounge chair, dining table and chairs retain broadly corresponding placement and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The dining pendant remains in place, but a recessed ceiling light is added at upper left."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position/framing/aspect/handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images have a 3:2 aspect ratio and closely corresponding framing and handedness; principal foreground landmarks align approximately."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Added recessed lighting and newly resolved kitchen fixtures prevent an object-preservation pass."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Too little identifiable structural timber is exposed to judge the stain reliably."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair infill and stove/pipe read black; concealed beams and firewood liner cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Stone reads grey, but its large chunky blocks and pronounced relief do not convincingly express the requested thin linear Ashlar treatment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The main fireplace front and seat are behind the chimney."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls have a warm pale mineral finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Floor is noticeably amber/brown rather than light wood; the entry stone is insufficiently visible to verify."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "A stainless pyramid hood and dark cabinetry are suggested, but counter colour and finish cannot be reliably assessed at this distance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dining pendant is an opal globe suspended on a black rod."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Walnut is clear, but the bookcase reads predominantly as wood cabinetry rather than an expressed black steel frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible table and chairs match the requested palette; eight-seat capacity is occluded."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The compact stove and pipe read matte black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel and seat are outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible slim vertical black infill accompanies warm timber rails and treads."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added upper-left recessed light.",
        "Background opening and kitchen fixture depiction depart from the native frame.",
        "Stone appears too chunky for the requested linear Ashlar finish.",
        "Bookcase lacks clearly expressed black steel framing."
      ],
      "summary": "Attractive and convincingly photographic, but fails binding object/layout preservation. Return to spatial correction and renewed comparison before finishing; this is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-kitchen-island-02",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-kitchen-island-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen rear wall, left circulation zone and foreground right return retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph introduces a clearly framed exterior window behind the left stair railing where the native frame shows a plain grey recess. The main kitchen window retains its broad proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling, diagonal overhead steel beam and upper clerestory arrangement remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The fireplace assembly is outside this framing; only a partial side bench and log compartment appear at far left."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left railing remains in the same location with vertical dark bars."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No identifiable bookcase is exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Island footprint, induction position, pyramid hood/chimney, rear cabinets, pantry fronts and dishwasher retain their visible arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial sofa and foreground chair remain in corresponding positions and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both opal pendants retain their black rods, ceiling mounts and relative positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with closely corresponding island corners, beam direction, foreground occlusions and left/right relationships."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The newly depicted framed window in the left circulation area changes the architectural content."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible upper timber reads as dark warm brown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated exposed steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Large beam and visible railing read as black; other steel components are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No masonry wall is exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace and front seat are outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm off-white, softly textured appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm timber flooring and the dark left entry zone are visible. However, wood also replaces the native pale kitchen floor."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three finishes are clearly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both pendants match the requested appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a partial dark chair is visible; the dining ensemble cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with floating plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel and seat are outside the view."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible railing has slim vertical black bars; channel, treads and handrail materials are insufficiently exposed."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added framed exterior window behind the left stair railing requires spatial reconciliation.",
        "Pale native kitchen flooring becomes timber in the photograph; this is a separate material change."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with strong kitchen finishes and closely preserved framing. Fail for the added left-background window; return to spatial correction before renewed photographic review. This is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-entry-arrival-02",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-entry-arrival-02/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Lake glazing, dining area, left nook connection and right fireplace wall retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The left-background nook enclosure changes: the native broad grey opening/background becomes a smaller rectangular lake window surrounded by substantial white wall. Main Great Room glazing divisions appear retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling planes, timber spacing and crossing black steel members correspond."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible right-edge chimney, partial firebox and projecting stone frontage remain in corresponding positions. The cropped view cannot establish the complete raised assembly."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair geometry is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No bookcase is sufficiently visible for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The visible foreground cabinet/counter envelope is retained. Hood and remaining kitchen fixtures are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two main sofas, leather armchair, glass coffee table, dining set and partial nook seating retain their arrangement and approximate scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible pendant globes, including the cropped left globe, and visible recessed lights and chimney sconces correspond."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames have matching 3:2 proportions and corresponding foreground furniture, ceiling intersections and window landmarks; no obvious mirroring or reframing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The altered nook window and surrounding wall introduce an architectural change beyond material finishing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Roof timbers read as dark stained wood against warm ceiling boards."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible structural steel reads consistently black. Stair, bookcase frames and firewood liner cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney has grey, horizontally coursed linear stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped firebox edge and stone frontage are shown; appliance elevation and complete front-only seat are unassessable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm off-white, subtly textured plaster appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Warm light wood flooring is evident; the entry stone zone is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Visible cabinetry and counter read as walnut and muted olive; the required hood is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible pendants have glowing opal globes and slender black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the assessable view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The dining set reads as a walnut table with eight black chairs."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is not shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The Oriel seat and its underside are not clearly shown."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stairs are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Photographic quality and attractiveness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Convincing fabric, wood grain, glass reflections and daylight create an attractive architectural photograph."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Left-background nook opening and surrounding wall differ from the binding native frame."
      ],
      "summary": "Photographically convincing and attractive, but the nook opening change prevents acceptance. Return to spatial correction and renewed comparison."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-nook-window-seat-03",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-nook-window-seat-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone/stove wall left, Oriel wall ahead and bookcase right retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible Oriel front and narrow left return, plus adjacent tall glazing, retain broadly matching outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Photograph adds substantial dark perimeter timbers beneath the ceiling that are absent from the binding native frame. The timber-lined ceiling also changes the visible ceiling junction."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace/chimney/hearth/seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible freestanding stove, flue and stone backing retain their placement and proportions. Main Rumford and front hearth seat are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground timber rail and vertical dark infill retain the same arrangement; lower construction is cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right-side shelving retains its location, shelf arrangement and approximate proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets/island/hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oriel cushion remains within the recess; no additional movable furniture appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No interior light fixtures are visibly added or removed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position/framing/aspect/handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames use a 3:2 aspect and closely matching perspective, landmark placement and handedness."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Added ceiling timbers introduce architectural objects absent from the native frame."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible added timbers have a dark walnut appearance, although their addition fails geometry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair infill and bookcase framing read as dark black metal; exact coating cannot be established visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey rectangular ashlar courses provide the requested general appearance; this is not product verification."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Main fireplace and front seat are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oriel surround reads as warm white with subtle mineral texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor is warm light wood; entry stone is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Pendant locations are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right-side bookcase combines dark framing with walnut-toned shelving."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining area is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Black stove and vertical flue are clearly visible at left."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Recessed cushion, thin dark underside and continuous plaster below preserve the floating appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground guard has slim vertical black bars with warm timber rail; channel and treads are cropped."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Substantial ceiling perimeter timbers were added relative to the exact native frame."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, but fails the binding geometry comparison because of added ceiling timbers. Return to spatial correction and renewed native review before finishing."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-nook-stove-03",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-nook-stove-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Bookcase wall, chimney faces and adjoining living/dining space retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible background windows and left entry opening retain their apparent outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling boundaries and cropped timbers remain consistent; the left ceiling changes from pale to timber finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Nook stove, pipe, pad and chimney retain their placement and proportions. Main Rumford and front seat are concealed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stair opening, timber rail and vertical steel infill remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Shelf arrangement, books and lower closed storage retain their count and placement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen components cannot be assessed from this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, lounge chair, dining table and chairs retain their arrangement and apparent scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible dining pendant remains in the same position."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2, with closely corresponding chimney, stove, shelving and railing landmarks; no reversal is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph adds projecting pale baseboard trim around the left entry wall where the native frame has a plain wall-to-floor junction."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The limited visible overhead timber reads dark brown."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair infill and bookcase framing read black; concealed beams and firewood liner cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Grey colour is appropriate, but the chimney reads as chunky, deeply textured rectangular blocks rather than restrained thin linear ashlar."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The main fireplace frontage is behind the chimney."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm pale tone and subtle plaster texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood flooring and a dark stone entry zone are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside the visible view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dining pendant has an opal globe and black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dark framing and warm walnut shelves/storage are legible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dining furniture matches the palette; all eight seats cannot be counted through the occlusion."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Compact black stove and black flue are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seat and its underside are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Slim vertical black infill, timber rail and timber treads are visible."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Added baseboard trim requires spatial correction and renewed review.",
        "Chimney stone is too chunky for the requested thin linear ashlar appearance.",
        "Left ceiling changes from the native pale surface to wood cladding."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with closely preserved framing and principal objects. Fails strict object fidelity because of added baseboards; stone appearance also needs refinement. Technical review only, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-kitchen-island-03",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-kitchen-island-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "material_only",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen rear wall, right return and left circulation opening retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rear window, clerestories and visible door openings retain substantially matching outlines and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling, adjoining sloped ceiling and major beam silhouettes remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace/chimney/hearth/seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this camera; the island hood is visible instead."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left stair opening and railing remain in place; treads and channel are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No bookcase is sufficiently exposed for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets/island/hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Island, induction surface, pyramid hood, rear cabinetry, sink and dishwasher retain their arrangement and approximate proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial sofa, foreground chair and left bench retain corresponding positions and scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both pendants retain their rod locations, relative sizes and hanging positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position/framing/aspect/handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 with closely corresponding island corners, hood, window and right-wall boundary; no mirroring is evident."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear substantive addition or removal is evident in the visible interior."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible adjoining roof timbers read as dark warm walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The prominent beam across the kitchen opening reads as brown wood with grain rather than black powder-coated steel. Visible stair bars remain black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No masonry wall is exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace frontage is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm pale mineral finish, although golden lighting makes them creamier."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood and the dark entry-floor zone are visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three finishes are recognizable and attractively rendered."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two softly luminous opal globes hang from black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a cropped foreground chair is visible; table and seating arrangement cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The exposed railing segment retains slim vertical black bars; full stair construction is obscured."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Prominent opening beam has acquired a wood appearance instead of black powder-coated steel.",
        "The native pale kitchen floor becomes wood in the photograph; reconcile this surface assignment with the intended material plan."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with no clear major geometry or camera drift. Correct the steel-beam finish and reconcile the kitchen flooring before release. This is a visual review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-entry-arrival-03",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-entry-arrival-03/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Lake glazing, left adjoining-room opening and right fireplace wall retain their orientation and relationships."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both tall glazing banks retain their visible mullions, horizontal divisions, sloping heads and intervening solid pier."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Ceiling planes, timber spacing and intersecting black steel members correspond to the native frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible right-edge chimney, partial firebox and projecting charcoal stone platform retain their outlines. Full aperture and side storage are outside this framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No stair components are clearly exposed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the visible composition."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The cropped foreground counter and cabinet retain their footprint and outline. Hood and remaining kitchen fixtures are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two principal sofas, lounge chair, glass coffee table, eight dining chairs, dining table and visible adjoining-room seating correspond in placement and apparent scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Three visible pendant globes, including the cropped left globe, two ceiling downlights and two chimney sconces retain their positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both images use a 3:2 frame with matching architectural intersections, furniture occlusions and edge crops; no evident reframing or mirroring."
        },
        {
          "check": "Added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No identifiable interior additions or removals. Exterior scenery, reflections and surface detail provide photographic finishing."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed roof timbers read as dark walnut against warm wood ceiling infill."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible architectural steel reads consistently black; stair, bookcase and liner finishes cannot be assessed here."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible chimney uses grey, horizontally coursed stone with varied linear lengths."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible fireplace frontage retains a raised charcoal stone platform; the complete appliance arrangement is cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm ivory tone and subtle mineral texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible wood flooring meets the requested warm light appearance. Entry stone is outside this view; visible hearth stone is charcoal."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible foreground cabinetry is walnut with a subdued olive counter. Stainless hood is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible globes read as softly illuminated opal glass suspended on black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No bookcase is exposed sufficiently for assessment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Dining table reads as walnut and its eight chairs remain black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel and its under-seat wall are outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Stair is outside the frame."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this camera: no concrete geometry, object or camera departure is evident. The photograph is convincing and attractive, with credible upholstery, wood, glass and warm daylight. Cropped or hidden preferences remain unverified; this is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-kitchen-island-04",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-kitchen-island-04/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen and adjoining hall walls retain their orientation and returns."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Large kitchen window, vertical divisions, clerestories and hall openings remain visually consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling, black steel beam and adjoining timber ceiling retain their geometry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible hall railing retains its position and vertical infill."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No identifiable bookcase is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Cabinet banks, island, induction surface and pyramid chimney hood retain their arrangement and proportions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial sofa, foreground chair and side bench remain in corresponding positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two island pendants retain their locations and black suspension rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 and corresponding architectural landmarks align closely without mirroring."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The photograph shows an additional tall curved tap-like fitting immediately right of the main sink faucet; the native frame shows one faucet."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible adjoining roof timber reads as dark warm walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible beam and railing read as consistent black steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Fireplace masonry is outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm pale mineral finish with restrained texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood and darker entry stone are visible. Replacing the native kitchen floor placeholder with wood is intentional."
        },
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three finishes are clearly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two softly glowing opal globes hang on black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the visible scope."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a partial foreground chair appears; the dining ensemble cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black steel stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible railing has slim vertical black infill; treads and channel are obscured."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Additional curved faucet-like hardware beside the sink changes the native object inventory."
      ],
      "summary": "Attractive and convincingly photographic, with closely preserved framing and strong material fidelity. The added sink fitting prevents acceptance; return it for object correction and renewed review."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-nook-stove-04",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-nook-stove-04/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney faces, adjoining bookcase wall and background dining wall retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left and dining-area openings retain their locations and proportions; no opening is added."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The limited ceiling and timber portions visible at upper right remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace/chimney/hearth/seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Nook stove, vertical pipe, rectangular floor pad and reduced chimney envelope remain in place. Main Rumford and front seat are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stairwell, timber handrails, black posts and vertical infill retain their arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Tall two-column bookcase, shelf divisions, lower closed storage and narrow entry bookcase are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets/island/hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen fixtures cannot be assessed from this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, foreground lounge chair, dining table and chairs retain their placement and comparable scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The single visible suspended pendant retains its location and black suspension; its rounded finish improves the native faceted proxy."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position/framing/aspect/handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames have a 3:2 aspect ratio and closely corresponding stove, chimney, bookcase and stair landmarks, with unchanged handedness."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No clear object addition or omission is visible. Exterior scenery and sunlight are appearance treatments."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "The small visible roof-member portions read dark brown; broader coverage is unavailable."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair steel and bookcase framing read black. Beam and firewood-liner finishes are obscured."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Chimney finish reads as thin horizontal grey ledgestone, replacing the chunky native texture."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The main fireplace front and seat are behind the chimney."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible walls have a warm off-white, softly textured finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main flooring reads warm light wood; the entry stone is too obscured to verify separately."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen finishes and hood are outside the visible field."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dining pendant has an opal globe and black suspension."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Bookcases combine dark framing with walnut shelves and cabinetry."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible dining furniture follows the requested palette; all eight seats cannot be counted through occlusion."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Compact stove, pipe and pad remain black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel seat and supporting wall are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stairs D1 vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Slim vertical black infill, dark support and warm timber rail/treads remain visible."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this camera: convincing, attractive photographic finishing with no clear geometry, object or camera departure. Warm lighting, walnut and linear grey stone work well together. Occluded features remain unverified; this is technical review, not owner approval."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-nook-window-seat-04",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-nook-window-seat-04/photo-review.json",
      "status": "pass",
      "failure_type": "none",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Stone chimney left, Oriel wall ahead and bookcase right retain their orientation and relationships."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oriel front and visible glazed side return, black perimeter frame and adjacent tall glazing retain their proportions and divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible ceiling edge and plane remain consistent; roof beams and timbers are outside this view."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace/chimney/hearth/seat",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Freestanding stove, vertical pipe and stone backing retain their placement and scale. Oriel seat remains within the opening. Rumford and front hearth seat are outside frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Foreground handrail corner and vertical infill retain their arrangement; lower stair construction is cropped."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right bookcase retains its shelf arrangement, position and cropped extent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets/island/hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen fixtures are outside frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Window-seat cushion retains its envelope; no additional furniture appears."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No light fixtures are visible in either frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position/framing/aspect/handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both use a 3:2 frame with consistent perspective, cropping and left/right order. No material reframing is apparent."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "No identifiable interior additions or removals. Exterior scenery and sunlight replace the native glazing's schematic appearance."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Roof timbers are outside frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stair infill and bookcase framing read as dark black metal."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Grey mixed-tone rectangular ashlar reads in horizontal courses; exact product and sample colour cannot be certified visually."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Great Room fireplace is outside frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Oriel surround has a warm white, subtly textured finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible floor is warm light wood; entry stone is outside frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Kitchen is outside frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Pendant locations are outside frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Right bookcase shows walnut shelves with dark framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Dining furniture is outside frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible stove and flue have a restrained matte-black finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Thin dark frame and pale cushion sit above continuous wall-matching plaster, preserving the floating appearance."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stairs D1 vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible railing has slim vertical dark bars and a warm timber handrail; channel and treads are cropped."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [],
      "summary": "Pass for this camera: no concrete geometry, object or camera departure identified. The photograph is convincing and attractive, with realistic daylight, material texture and a clear floating window-seat treatment. Hidden features remain unverified."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-kitchen-island-05",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-kitchen-island-05/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen rear wall, left circulation opening and right foreground return retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and divisions",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Rear kitchen window and visible clerestories retain their positions and principal divisions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling, large black beam and upper timber/clerestory arrangement remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "The fireplace assembly is outside this frame; only an adjacent bench/log-storage fragment is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left stair opening and vertical guard remain in place."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No complete bookcase is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Main cabinet masses, island footprint, induction position and pyramid hood retain the native arrangement."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible sofa, foreground chair and bench fragments remain in corresponding positions."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two suspended pendants retain their rods, ceiling attachment positions and relative scale."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both frames are 3:2 with matching handedness and closely corresponding architectural framing."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added, removed or changed objects and hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "The native angular faucet becomes a taller rounded gooseneck. The dishwasher gains a prominent projecting metal bar handle absent from the native frame."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut roof timbers",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible upper-left timber reads medium warm brown rather than dark walnut."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible beam, stair bars and pendant rods read black."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Small left masonry patch reads as grey horizontal thin-course stone."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford and charcoal front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm pale mineral finish, strongly warmed by sunlight."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal entry stone",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood flooring and dark circulation/entry flooring are visible. Replacing the native pale kitchen placeholder with wood is permitted."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut kitchen, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three treatments are visibly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Two luminous opal globes hang on black rods."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only foreground furniture fragments are shown; the dining arrangement cannot be verified."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside the frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 vertical black stair bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible guard portion has slim vertical black bars; channel and treads are obscured."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Faucet geometry changed from angular to rounded gooseneck.",
        "Projecting dishwasher bar handle added.",
        "Visible roof timber is lighter than the requested dark walnut."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with largely faithful framing and room masses. Hardware changes prevent a geometry pass and require spatial correction and renewed review. The wood kitchen floor is an allowed preference correction."
    },
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-kitchen-island-06",
      "review_file": "tmp/room_template/2026-11-10-preferred-living/photo-reviews/preferred-kitchen-island-06/photo-review.json",
      "status": "fail",
      "failure_type": "layout_object",
      "photorealistic": true,
      "geometry_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Wall orientation",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Kitchen back wall, right foreground return and left circulation opening retain their orientation."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opening count, size and division",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Wide kitchen window, its vertical divisions and visible clerestories remain consistent."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ceiling slope, beams and timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Flat kitchen ceiling, diagonal foreground steel beam and upper timber/clerestory arrangement are retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Fireplace, chimney, hearth and seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Main fireplace and front seat are outside this frame; only part of the side bench/log storage is visible."
        },
        {
          "check": "Stair",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible left stair guard retains its position and vertical infill."
        },
        {
          "check": "Bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "No identifiable bookcase is exposed sufficiently for comparison."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen cabinets, island and hood",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Major cabinet, island, induction and pyramid-hood envelopes remain consistent, but the curved native faucet becomes a tall angular fixture. The native sink's visible internal division is not clearly retained."
        },
        {
          "check": "Furniture count, placement and scale",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Partial sofa, foreground black chair and side bench remain in corresponding positions and scales."
        },
        {
          "check": "Light fixture count and position",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both opal pendants retain their black rods, ceiling mounts and relative locations."
        },
        {
          "check": "Camera position, framing, aspect and handedness",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Matching 3:2 framing and corresponding island, beam, hood and wall landmarks show no evident reversal or significant camera drift."
        },
        {
          "check": "No added or removed objects, lights, decor or hardware",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Faucet hardware was redesigned rather than photographically finished."
        }
      ],
      "preference_checks": [
        {
          "check": "Dark walnut stained roof timbers",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible upper timber reads as dark stained wood."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black powder-coated steel",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Exposed beam and visible stair infill read as consistent black steel."
        },
        {
          "check": "Ashlar Muskoka Grey linear stone",
          "result": "fail",
          "reason": "Visible left stone reads as regular rectangular coursed blocks rather than the requested thin linear Ashlar treatment."
        },
        {
          "check": "Raised Rumford with charcoal stone front seat",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Outside this camera."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm white limewash walls",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Walls have a warm pale mineral finish."
        },
        {
          "check": "Warm light wood floor with charcoal stone at entry",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Warm wood continues into the kitchen as intended; dark stone marks the left entry/circulation area. Replacing the native pale floor placeholder is permitted."
        },
        {
          "check": "Kitchen dark walnut, honed olive counters and stainless pyramid hood",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "All three finishes are clearly represented."
        },
        {
          "check": "Opal glass pendants on black rods",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Both visible pendants match this direction."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black steel and walnut bookcases",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Bookcases are outside the useful visible area."
        },
        {
          "check": "Walnut dining table and black chairs",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Only a partial black chair is visible; table and seating count cannot be assessed."
        },
        {
          "check": "Black freestanding stove",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Nook stove is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "Small Oriel seat with plaster below",
          "result": "not-visible",
          "reason": "Oriel is outside this frame."
        },
        {
          "check": "D1 stairs with vertical black steel bars",
          "result": "pass",
          "reason": "Visible guard portion has slim vertical black bars and a timber rail; treads and channel are obscured."
        }
      ],
      "defects": [
        "Curved native faucet replaced by angular hardware.",
        "Sink division requires correction or clearer verification against the native frame.",
        "Visible stone lacks the requested thin linear Ashlar character."
      ],
      "summary": "Convincingly photographic and attractive, with strong overall framing fidelity. Hardware drift prevents acceptance; return to spatial/object correction and renewed review. Stone appearance also needs refinement."
    }
  ],
  "manual_overrides": [
    {
      "attempt_id": "preferred-great-room-wide-02",
      "reviewer_status": "fail",
      "final_status": "pass",
      "date": "2026-11-10",
      "reason": "Reviewer reported an added seating rug, but the model contains greatroom::natural-wool-flatweave-rug (X462.8-582.8, Y356.8-476.8) which projects into the bottom-left of this exact camera (corner at pixel 364,861); the photograph shows that rug. No other defects reported."
    }
  ]
}